review of nominations and VOTING for (very nebulously defined) ELECTRONIC DANCE TRACKS of the 00s

i am whittlin' it down

:-(

feel better tim

Yeah, best wishes Tim. Be healthy.

Oh I'm going home tomorrow, no dramas, just saying that I'm on the case.

Okay, I've voted.

Ballot in. Left a bunch of stuff I nominated off, rediscovered the Luomo remix of Black Dice's "Smiling Off" and gave that some love instead - good fallback when DJing a mid-00s gallery opening.

I'm going to try and vote tonight but it's probably worth extending the deadline rather than running a poll with a tiny number of voters?

I have a shortlist of 80 now but I agree with extending the deadline because 1000+ nominations is so daunting.

Amazed potential high-placers LCD's Yeah and Katy B's On a Mission aren't in there but I guess I should have nominated them myself instead of kvetching now.

Get well soon Tim.

terrence parker - your love

is from 1996 btw

didnt see all the kdjs but j.a.n is 90s also

i think "yeah" is not electronic enough and "on a mission" is too pop for our participants

i would consider extending the deadline but i would want a roll call of who needs an extension, so that i know when to start counting ballots.

The thing with a theme like this, unlike a single-artist poll, is that there are so many factions - there are producers, labels, even genres I've ignored entirely and I'm sure that will be the case for a lot of voters, so you need a certain number of voters before any meaningful overlap will occur. I can see most of my tracks dying a lonely death if there are less than 20 ballots.

just sent in my ballot too.
at some point I had to stop splitting hairs between adjacent tunes out of the 50 and hope for approx current favour/ranking within around 10 spots, except for the all important Top 5/Top 10. loved hearing (relistening to) many of these tunes again!

^
this

i'll have one in within the next couple of hours. surprisingly happy with it. ps. midi rain 'always' was a biggish revival tune for ellen allien amongst others but is from like 1991.

I vote for extension

so do I

whatever i just scanned the list and made a shortlist of the ones i could hum (about 75) and then just got rid of the microhouse

ok here is something i am thinking - in the meantime, could we crowd-source the composer and label for each track?

then we could also tabulate top artists and top labels

For whatever it's worth, even though I'm a fan of Avalanches/Basement Jaxx/Daft Punk/The Knife/LCD Soundsystem, I'm probably gonna leave that stuff off.

sent

:_D

I vote for extension

― ┗|∵|┓ (sic), Wednesday, May 30, 2012 10:37 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

so do I

― boxedjoy, Wednesday, May 30, 2012 10:41 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

yes.

I've got swept up in a lot of stuff this week I didn't count on. I can still dash one off but it won't be as considered as I'd like. So yes, an extension if at all possible.

extension would be great

Working on my ballet now

plie-se extend

Gonna hit the original deadline I think (a bit of a rarity for me in all aspects of life!)

Inflation really stands up I think, what an atmosphere that track has, it's very, ahem, cough, cinematic.

some how i never noticed this until now. but no 'love story'? pffft.

Working on my ballet now

Ahhh, I knew I should have nominated something from Shut Up and Dance!

I kind of hate Mathew Jonson, but I'm finding it really hard to remove Marionette from my list, despite it being a completely joyless experience to dance to.

Removing it 'cause I've got so many Cobblestone Jazz tracks in there and I much prefer those to dance to.

there's always typerope!

done! that was emotional.

Nah, that went out far earlier. I find his solo stuff a little too dry. If there was any solo effort of his I'd pick, it would be this remix:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7CFL60yk0rw

Anyway, this was super tough, but going through the list brought up a few "so THATS what that track was called" moments and a few new discoveries. These are the closest eleven to making it, that I had to cut off in the end.

kassem mosse - 12 a1
akufen - deck the house
donato dozzy - gol
akufen - skidoos
efdemin - lohn & brot
mosca - bax
blawan - getting me down
cottam - 003b
mala - anti war dub
instra:mental - end credits
fish go deep - the cure and the cause (dennis ferrer remix)

(x-post)

sooo will this get extended or not? because I feel sleepy and I want to make my ballot tomorriw

Extend it over the weekend, but no further, please! I'd love to see the results next week.

Surely anyone who's interested in the poll can write down a list of 50 tracks over one weekend? It took me like 30 minutes to come up with my ballot.

I have to say I don't really see the point in posting in a poll like this if you're not interested in spending some time listening to tracks you are unfamiliar with, but I guess people have their own reasons.

I'm having enough trouble whittling down the tracks I loved at the time to worry about taking on new ones.

More fun to discover things in the countdown imo.

please extension yes, i have a lot of but-who-do-i-love-best listening left to do

Matt OTM. I see absolutely no point in diligently plugging through hundreds of nominations and then attempting to weigh up new discoveries against tunes you've loved for years. That's what the roll out is for. I don't like polls to feel like homework.

Son.sine - Upekah

― mmmm, Sunday, 22 April 2012

did not expect to see this nominated!

might vote

not sure where my nomination stl moving deep went

wait im mixing that son.sine up with something else. good record all the same tho

please extension yes, i have a lot of but-who-do-i-love-best listening left to do

― dethklok piccalo (c sharp major), Thursday, May 31, 2012 9:18 AM (48 minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

^^