Thread for coordinating the order and timing of ILM ballot polls

that's the spirit! :)

The Beatles and XTC one after another wd def mix things up a bit

Beatles would be nice just to have an artist actually worth doing a poll for

Beatles...zzz. I mean, it would actually be fun because there are so many good songs, but it seems so played.

In their stead, I claim Madonna. Not sure where I am on the list—don't want #4—but I'll go later.

Actually, strike that. I don't want to handle a Madonna poll.

(My first choice of words was "I don't want to do Madonna", but there's really no good way to address that.)

Beatles would be nice just to have an artist actually worth doing a poll for

Worst Beatles song ever

1. pet shop boys - billy dods
2. Beatles - Mark G
3. beach boys - iatee
4. __________
5. __________
6. __________
7. Led Zeppelin - WmC

I can move Zep up to 5 or 6 if it fits the schedule better.

all of those should be great. anyone up to doing some producers or labels?

are we waiting for the Manics poll to finish before the PSB can begin?

Zep will be fun

I was going to wait until the polling closed in the Manic's thread, 22nd iirc and then start the PSB poll. The Manics reveal can go on while the PSB votes come in.

I Love Organised Music Polls

you are all so crazy

omg the Beach Boys one is gonna be impossible. looking forward to that one

hyped for the PSBs poll. expecting high placing for My Funny Uncle

Prince would be my no.1 choice for a future poll though i think, just because i like the discovery of rarities aspect, and with led zep and steely dan everyone who's a big fan sort of knows every track

true-ish, although Steely Dan has some great unreleased songs most people don't know that i'd be youtubing all over the place trying to drum up support for

what happens if someone starts a rogue ballot poll

eh like 5 xp

for the most part the dan aren't one of those 'treasure trove of unreleased stuff' bands. they have those early demos which aren't super interesting and then the gaucho stuff which is great but that's about it.

to me the interesting part of these threads isn't so much the 'which rarity might sneak in' as much as the enthusiastic discussion and dissection of 'why' these tracks are the best.

lol jordan

for the most part the dan aren't one of those 'treasure trove of unreleased stuff' bands. they have those early demos which aren't super interesting and then the gaucho stuff which is great but that's about it.

― iatee, Saturday, June 18, 2011 4:51 PM (4 minutes ago) Bookmark

and "This All Too Mobile Home" and "Westside Story"!!! but yeah i see your point.

what happens if someone starts a rogue ballot poll

― J0rdan S., Saturday, June 18, 2011 8:49 PM (2 hours ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

autobanned.

banished to the cape.

forced to post on wdyll in underwear.

Is this the status as of now still?

1. pet shop boys - billy dods
2. Beatles - Mark G
3. beach boys - iatee
4. __________
5. __________
6. __________
7. Led Zeppelin - WmC

Because I bailed on the Madonna idea, but Guided By Voices keeps nagging at me and I'm finally giving in. So put me down for Guided By Voices at #6.

1. pet shop boys - billy dods
2. Beatles - Mark G
3. beach boys - iatee
4. __________
5. __________
6. Guided By Voices - Johnny Fever
7. Led Zeppelin - WmC

the winner of some dude's poll can be zero I guess idk

I'm not in charge, somebody be in charge

Cool -- without objection, I'm going to bump LZ to 5.

1. pet shop boys - billy dods
2. Beatles - Mark G
3. beach boys - iatee
4. __________
5. Led Zeppelin - WmC
6. Guided By Voices - Johnny Fever
7. __________

Something dancey/electronic, or a label poll at 4? Madonna would be great if anybody wants to take up the challenge.

When I started thinking about remixes, etc. the nightmare became vivid.

guh...I didn't think of that. votesplitters...

Votes are for the song, write-in/on for remixes...

So when is it kicking off for the PSB's?

Are we waiting on the end of the Manics one first? Fair enough.

Suggsting: some sort of generic poll-thread title, e.g.

ILX Tracks Poll No 1 : Pet Shop Boys

I like the uniformity in titling idea. Easier to search for in the future.

Any chance we could move either the Beatles or the Beach Boys back a bit? It's getting so canonical white dudes that there'll be minimal interest in doing anything else after we've trawled through everyone in Q magazine.

Well, everyone else has backed off, timewise.

There's the Manics one up at the mo, the Pavement one just finished, the MC Tunes is taking it's time, just like his second album, so the pace is fairly leisurely.

I hesitate to suggest, but the Beach Boys' "Smile" is coming out fairly soon (the single is out already), so...

(hopefully) BIG 50s decade trax poll coming sometime in July as well. Would hate for it to face one of these head to head, so I'll figure out what week that will roll out and let whomever is coordinating these know so a gap in the flow can be predetermined.

I mean, yeah I'd love someone to do a James Brown one, but do we collectively have the required knowledge to vote? I mean, I have the "Star Time" box which is pretty nice and all encompassing as these things go, but is that enough?

There are shitloads of James Brown fans on ILM, surely?

If we want to make it a little less white then a labels poll such as Motown, Stax or Trojan or a genre poll such as disco (1975-80) or Northern Soul would fit in. I think a Wu-Tang and its members poll would be good too.

Any chance we could move either the Beatles or the Beach Boys back a bit? It's getting so canonical white dudes that there'll be minimal interest in doing anything else after we've trawled through everyone in Q magazine.
--Matt DC

yeah you can move me to 9 or something

A Motown poll would be neato keen-o.

You can put me in to run Prince if you like - having fun doing the Manics one.

I guess Neil Young and Dylan are other ones that would be good due to the huge discogs, but i do agree on the less rock white dudes quota. Think a Jacksons one would be good - so Michael, Janet, Jackson 5, any family member.

I'd love to see a Stax or Motown poll. The problem with genre polls like "disco" is that they descend into a flamewar about what does or does not belong to the genre.

hmmm should I do a P-Funk poll

I dunno if I have the spreadsheetery skills/will to do this tbh

I was toying with doing a Disco one. Keep those wide open is the best way I say, and let the voters decide whether they're happy with a track as disco. It worked fine on the showcasing poll, except that The Cure sneaked into the top 5.

Oh man, my job is Excel-based so now I imagining formatting possibilities and vlookup potential.. but I'm only good for Belle & Sebastian, Pulp or Modest Mouse, I'm not nearly enough of a completist for most other bands now that Blur's been done.

Alright, I made an excel file that should be useful, hopefully.
http://www.megaupload.com/?d=ZQBPGXI6

Basically it's got a sheet where you dump in the songs and their ranks, and a formula that compares rank to point value which is listed on a separate sheet. Then there are suggestions and examples for making a pivot table to corral the data, or a suggestion for doing it manually.

I hope it's useful! /nerd

^^if I didn't make it clear.. I'm really hoping someone will find it useful. This is why I chose computers over English ;)

I'll do Pulp at #4 if no one else objects? Understand if too close to Pulp/Manics/Boos. Mostly I just want to play with my Excel file now.

eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

Giving up Classic Rock may prove my greatest regret as an ilxor, I have great feelings about that poll. But SD will def do a better job (my track record on these things is pretty iffy). Hopefully I can get it together by the time of the grand Billy Joel Poel.

i will sit at the bar and put bread in yr jar iirc

i heard that damn song at the grocery store today and it made me want to yell at someone. looking forward to classic rock memory lane poll tbrr. can't wait to see how high "burnin for you" places. Time to play ~b-sides~.

Giving up Classic Rock may prove my greatest regret as an ilxor, I have great feelings about that poll. But SD will def do a better job (my track record on these things is pretty iffy). Hopefully I can get it together by the time of the grand Billy Joel Poel.

― Doctor Casino, Saturday, December 28, 2013 12:47 PM (1 hour ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

haha listen man if you wanted to grab the steering wheel or split some duties, i'd have no problem with that, totally your call.

Can I claim 105 for a New Pornographers/AC Newman tracks and albums poll?

re: this thread new New Pornographers

Ha, thanks SD but I don't wanna be captain take-back. Would be decidedly un-rock, anyway!

Piano Man discussion does remind me that 'worst' classic rock would be a great, long ballot in and of itself.

American Pie would win that.

I'm gonna keep my place in line for Stiff Records, but I may change the topic at some point. Not sure it would be much of a draw after Stax only got 20-something ballots.

― Johnny Fever, Friday, December 27, 2013 12:55 AM

In the next master list update, can you change the Stiff poll to a Van Halen poll? Because VAN FUCKING HALEN.

YEEEEEESSSS

I'm going to start a new thread on 1/1 and will make that change, plus the Byrds, covers, New Pornographers additions.

thx boss

Piano Man discussion does remind me that 'worst' classic rock would be a great, long ballot in and of itself.

― Doctor Casino, Saturday, December 28, 2013 4:13 PM (5 hours ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

good point, i should definitely have a top 5 "most bad and hated" subpoll or something.

I'm going to start a new thread on 1/1 and will make that change, plus the Byrds, covers,

Uh, I meant covers instead of Byrds. I can do Byrds sometime down the road, but would rather not do back to back polls.

New thread:
ILM Ballot Polls for 2014 and beyond -- order, timing, "I would have voted if I'd known about it," etc