Year-End Critics' Polls '08

Thanks for the links. Will check that lindstrom album then.

Also released this year is this great Nigerian Highlife Compilation on soundway:

http://kinosport.tv/notebook/wp-content/uploads/2008/03/nigerian-special.jpg

Great song selection and beautiful artwork.

we should make a reissues of the year thread

I don't even know if I could make a top 10 out of things I heard this year, but...

people need to quit sleeping on the bug CD

I couldn't get into a mountain of one until the other day when I had a massive hangover and it was the only thing in the pile that made any sense. how is it not on any of these lists? also liked:

landed - how little will it take?
naked on the vague - blood pressure sessions
teeth mountain
some of that destroyer album

things I need to spend more time with: endless boogie, prurient

things I still haven't heard: the ex & getatchew mekurya, indian jewelry, made in mexico, usaisamonster, growing, no age, cut copy

things I tried to listen to but stopped because it felt like homework: marnie stern, ponytail, portishead, times new viking, guns n roses, vampire weekend

oh shit I meant to put that on the other thread

Uncut magazine

Top 20

1. Third - Portishead
2. Fleet Foxes - Fleet Foxes
3. Dear Science - TV On The Radio
4. For Emma, Forever Ago - Bon Iver
5. Vampire Weekend - Vampire Weekend
6. The Seldom Seen Kid - Elbow
7. Stainless Style – Neon Neon
8. Dig!!! Lazarus, Dig!!! Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds
9. Only By The Night - Kings Of Leon
10 22 Dreams - Paul Weller
11. Brighter Than Creation's Dark - Drive-by Truckers
12. Stay Positive - The Hold Steady
13. Litany of Echoes - James Blackshaw
14. Harps and Angels - Randy Newman
15. Made In The Dark - Hot Chip
16. Limbo, Panto - Wild Beasts
17. Seventh Tree - Goldfrapp
18. Real Emotional Trash - Stephen Malkmus
19. Rook - Shearwater
20. Evil Urges - My Morning Jacket

Very pleased to see James Blackshaw at number 13 on the Uncut list.

I didn't buy too much new suff this year, but the Nothing People LP stands out as something that would be in any lists I made.

i understand it's totally cliche to be like "omg yall lists suxxorz" but what is up with these? i'm glad RET is getting love though.

Fleet Foxes failing to get #1 in Uncut must be regarded as some sort of catastrophe for their PR people.

Seriously, what is up with My Morning Jacket making so many of these lists? That album had two or three good tracks and twelve average-to-total-shit songs. Any album that contains "The Librarian" and "Highly Suspicious" belongs nowhere near a best-of-year list.

Fleet Foxes payback innit.

They did get the inaugural Uncut Music Award however!

http://www.uncut.co.uk/blog/index.php?blog=13&p=1026&more=1&c=1&tb=1&pb=1

Since Dave Stelfox left Pitchfork I don't think they've gotten a new dancehall/reggae columnist so that means even less year-end critic coverage of reggae/dancehall

Pitchfork year-end reggae/dancehall coverage went up today here.

best 'noise' thing I heard this year was 'gongs of violence' by andrew coltrane. i think he has loads of discs and tapes out, they're probably all good. and pale fatal sister by hototogisu hit the spot w/ me

i loved solar bridge by emeralds, but don't see anything v. noise abt it

I'm conscious that I've almost entirely missed out on the noise/Wire-oriented side of things this year (a situation admittedly not helped by the delibidinising effect of Wire writers, some of the most turgid and joyless writers the music press has to offer). So their EOY list might be of practical use to me for catch up purposes.

The only other EOY list I find of active use is the OMM one, which, though generally crap and predictable, is good on World Music and I do tend to blue pencil those entries.

The Hot Chip album seemed to get a mixed reaction on its release but it sure ain't doing badly in the year end lists.

it's terrible except for "Shake a Fist"

best Hot Chip track of the year, by a mile: Supermayer's remix of "One Pure Thought"

I really like the first two-thirds of the Hot Chip album but then it totally falls apart. That Supermayer remix is great though.

i don't dislike hot chip by any means but calling that album the best of anything is a bit weird. though depressingly it does seem to be among the best of all the lists it's on :/

Supermayer's remix of "One Pure Thought"

does it sound anything like M83's 'Couleurs' (part of which reminds me of 'One Pure Thought' itself)?

It sounds like the DFA.

which also means it has great singles but the album is a little hard to make it through all the way

We're talking about a remix, not an album.

i thought we were talking about Hot Chip

There has only been one mention of Dragging A Dead Deer Up A Hill by Grouper, and it wasn't even by a publication...That album is so amazing. Might be #1 this year for me.

That's the retro shoegazing, dreamy, 4AD, slurred vocals, ambient, Yo La Tengoish group from Portland, right.

It's Liz Harris

Pfunkboy wins.

All her records are great.

Uncut cont.

50 Mercury Rev - Snowflake Midnight
49 Brian Wilson - That Lucky Old Sun
48 Byrne/Eno - Everything That Happens..
47 Sic Alps - USEZ
46 Pete Greenwood - Sirens
45 The Fall - Imperial Wax Solvent
44 REM - Accelerate
43 Joan as Police Woman - To Survive
42 Metallica - Death Magnetic
41 James Yorkston - When The Haar Rolls In
40 That Was The Week - s/t
39 Beck - Modern Guilt
38 Endless Boogie - Focus Level
37 Lambchop - OH(Ohio)
36 Earth - The Bees Made Honey In The Lions Skull
35 Toumani Diabate - The Mande Variations
34 Fuck Buttons - Street Horrrsing
33 Sigur Ros - Bollocks to typing this out on a BlackBerry
32 Flight of The Conchords - s/t
31 White Denim - Workout Holiday
30 Gnarls Barkley - The Odd Couple
29 Robert Foster - The Evangelist
28 The Felice Brothers - s/t
27 MGMT - Orcular Spectacular
26 Lucinda Williams - s/t
25 Jenny Lewis - Acid Tongue
24 Glasvegas - s/t
23 Black Mountain - In The Future
22 The Raconteurs - Consolers of The Lonely
21 Howlin Rain - Magnificent Fiend

(note: at least two of these are made up)

...the Nothing People LP stands out as something that would be in any lists I made

absolutely. a lot of good stuff on s-s this year.

26 Lucinda Williams - s/t

This one came out 20 years ago.

Sorry yeah, should be Little Honey.

thanks for 21-50 Mitchell!

Everyone's a critic--

RYM's Current Top Rated of 2008

1. David Gilmour- Live in Gdańsk
2. Portishead- Third
3. Opeth- Watershed
4. Esoteric- The Maniacal Vale
5. TV on the Radio- Dear Science
6. Fleet Foxes
7. Amon Amarth- Twilight of the Thunder God
8. Deerhunter- Microcastle / Weird Era Cont.
9. Muse- HAARP
10. Coldworld- Melancholie²
11. Nomo- Ghost Rock
12. Suspyre- When Time Fades...
13. Cult of Luna- Eternal Kingdom
14. Gojira- The Way of All Flesh
15. Thrice- The Alchemy Index: Volume III + IV - Air & Earth
16. Septic Flesh- Communion
17. Flight of the Conchords
18. Testament- The Formation of Damnation
19. Elbow- The Seldom Seen Kid
20. Sun Kil Moon- April
21. Erykah Badu- New Amerykah Part One (4th World War)
22. Bar Kokhba- Lucifer: Book of Angels Volume 10
23. Cut Copy- In Ghost Colours
24. Have a Nice Life- Deathconsciousness
25. Darkspace- Dark Space III

That RYM list will probably change/update in a few days.

It changes often but those positions have been steady for awhile now. There does seem to be an effort to knock that Gilmour album down though.

Presumably an effort of some sort put it there in the first place?

I really love that Have A Nice Life album. One of the finds of the year. And Esoteric is probably my joint fave of the year along with the Portishead.

it's already down to #8 ha. that list is way different even now, 4 hours later.

i don't think that list should even count since it'll continually change and morph for, you know, ever

i was referring to the david gilmour, btw

Thanks for posting these everyone. The next ones to usually come are:

Clash Magazine
Drowned In Sound
Muzzle Of Bees
Gorilla Vs. Bear
Fact Magazine
NME

Kerrang will be
1) Metallica - Boringly overrated album
2-24) Some emo shite of pretty boys with girly hair.
25) Token metal album.

RYM updates about once a month.. weird coincidence.

XLR8R magazine

Top 25 Albums of 2008
http://www.xlr8r.com/news/2008/11/top-25-portishead-daedelus-foals

Atlas Sound Let the Blind Lead Those Who See But Cannon Feel kranky

Beach House Devotion Carpark

Brenda Ray Walatta EM

Bun-B Il Trill Rap-a-lot

Daedelus Love to Make Music To Ninja Tune

Dizzee Rascal Maths + English Def Jux

Flying Lotus Los Angeles Warp

Foals Antidotes Sub Pop

Glass Candy Beatbox Italians Do It Better

Jeremy Jay A Place Where We Could Go K

Kelley Polar I need to Hold on While the Sky is Falling Environ

Lindstrøm Where You Go I Go Too Smalltown Supersound

Lone Lemurian Dealmaker

M83 Saturdays = Youth Mute

MGMT Oracular Spectacular Sony

The Notwist The Devil, You + Me Domino

Portishead Third Mercury

Syclops I've Got My Eye on You DFA

Spiritualized Songs in A & E Universal

The Mole High as the Sky Wagon Repair

Throw Me the Statue Moonbeams Secretly Canadian

Tobacco Fucked Up Friends anticon.

Xiu Xiu Women as Lovers Kill Rock Stars

Yelle Pop-Up Carolina

Zomes Zomes Holy Mountain

good list - jeremy jay is really good

UK jazz music monthly magazine - Jazzwise

Jazzwise Magazine - Albums of the Year 2008
http://tinyurl.com/5vweps

1 Dave Holland Sextet Pass It on Dare2
2 EST Leucocyte ACT
3 Django Bates and Stormchaser Spring Is Here (Shall We Dance) Lost Marble
4 Ambrose Akinmusire Prelude To Cora FSNT
5 Bobo Stenson Cantando ECM
6 Dave Douglas and Keystone Moonshine Greenleaf
7 Jazz Warriors Afropeans Destin-e
8 Joe Zawinul And The Zawinul Syndicate 75th BHM/Birdjam
9 Bill Frisell History Mystery Nonesuch
10 JD Allen I Am I Am Sunnyside