Rolling Teenpop 2007 Thread

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed
Not all messages are displayed: show all messages (2325 of them)
T-Squad:

The Truth Squad is a vocal and dance hip hop/pop- “super group” -comprised of four uniquely talented young performers that individually have mad skills in dance, electric vocals, and an unbelievable presence. They also share a unifying desire to fight lies and expose dishonesty. Pledging to stick together through thick and thin, the Truth Squad has set out to show how friendship and trust are the keys to a better world and best of all, they do it all through phat beats and tight moves.

They all have acting/dance resumes, one of them was a dancer in a Missy video (forget which one) and "Hollaback Girl."

Q: If you could change something about the pop scene today, what would it be?

Miki: Not to make it as provocative as it is and to make it more kid friendly. That's maybe one thing to change.

BOOOOOOORING.

nameom (nameom), Wednesday, 10 January 2007 01:08 (seventeen years ago) link

I assume Good Charlotte still count as teenpop. The only time I saw them was when they were touring behind the Young and the Hopeless. I was unimpressed. The following act (New Found Glory) had much more passion, and G.C. had something very 'precious' occurring with them. Lyrics like: "Girls don't like boys, girls like cars and money" really turned me off. Then they released the follow up: Chronicles of Life + Death, which sounded like they had been listening to a ton of Evanescence (which is to say, in my mind, very melodramatic, heavy).

So, just listened to their single off the new album, "The River." Which sounds like they've evolved into P!ATD and MCR. Benji's vocals are completely inscrutable for me compared to Young and the Hopeless. I don't want to sound like G.C. can't do anything right, and in fact, the song is pretty good - well-produced, a nice amount of angst. Yet it's hard to take G.C. seriously.

I know people on the AltPress forums are going to hate G.C., just because of who they are. [Random Mosher from the AltPress forums: "Stick your head in a tub of water for 10 minutes please. Good Charlotte is the worst, worst, worst, candy coated, cookie cutter, Tiger Beat, Poser, TRL babies, Pop-f*gs, scene killing *ssh*l*s I have ever heard or scene...EVER!"] And certainly, there is something inauthentic about the style change. Yet I can't ignore the fact that they sound better, more cohesive, on the single than they ever did. I only wish they had retained some of the spunk from Young + Hopeless, instead of going for the easy push buttons of their audience.

"As I walk through the valley
of the shadow of LA
The footsteps that were next to me
have gone their separate ways
I've seen enough now
to know that beautiful things
don't always stay that way"

Didn't "Welcome to the Jungle" do the same sentiment, but make it fun?

"Baptized in the river (on my own)
Baptized in the river (on my own)
I wanna be delivered"

Thursday does the religious-social intersection so much more convincingly, too. (Sugar in Sacrament).

Mordechai Shinefield (Mordy), Wednesday, 10 January 2007 08:26 (seventeen years ago) link

Link, btw: http://www.myspace.com/goodcharlotte
Also, to an AltPress discussion about it: http://www.altpress.com/moshpit/viewmessages.cfm?Forum=18&Topic=6881&srow=1&erow=15
Also, I reserve the right to completely change my mind numerous times as I continue to listen to it.

Mordechai Shinefield (Mordy), Wednesday, 10 January 2007 08:35 (seventeen years ago) link

The two mixes/remixes of that Good Charlotte song are appealing but the original mix is kind of 'whatever.' I like the chorus, though.

What Mordechai said about the clunkiness of Good Charlotte has always been something that bothered me. They're good for about three lines and then say something so cringeworthy I have to change the channel or whatever.

...wait, hang on, I was talking about 'Keep Your Hands Off My Girl,' I didn't realised 'The River' was the single. It's alright, it sounds like Funeral For A Friend crossed with Nightmare Of You.

Good Charlotte are sort of the in-laws of teenpop, I would've thought, since aside from the Hilary Duff connection (are they still going out?) they don't quite fit into the genre and are vaguely hated by it, despite having obvious similarities to a lot of teenpop.

This may be a really stupid question but I heard some Aimee Allen the other day- teenpop, yes?

Hazel Robinson (Moggy), Thursday, 11 January 2007 12:15 (seventeen years ago) link

Have you guys heard "Got Off Easy" on the Lillix album? Hopefully, the album will finally come out (there was some problem with their record label, I think) and maybe they'll do a video for that one too.

Tim Ellison = NUMBER ONE ADVOCATE OF YOU-KNOW-WHAT ON NU-ILX!!! (Tim Ellison), Thursday, 11 January 2007 19:58 (seventeen years ago) link

So apparently The N has a show called "Instant Star" that's like Hannah Montana conceptually (from like a year or two ago, proto-Hannah maybe?) about a big star with a big voice. "24 Hours" (original tune) and Garbage's "Stupid Girl." Anyone watch this thing?

nameom (nameom), Friday, 12 January 2007 03:23 (seventeen years ago) link

I used to watch Instant Star. It's very DeGrassi'ish. And it lacked the sweet heart that Hannah Montana had. It was basically about her hooking up with her ex-Boy Band producer, and fighting with her sister over who was cooler. Though I do remember there were a couple songs I enjoyed - but I wasn't posting on Rolling Teenpop at the time. It's kind of a darker Hannah Montana, much like everything on TheN seems to be darker than Disney. (Except Radio Free Roscoe, which was so very cute!)

Mordechai Shinefield (Mordy), Friday, 12 January 2007 03:42 (seventeen years ago) link

Here was my favorite song from that show:
"Waste My Time" (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pWu2p3v2pos).
It starts slow, almost hits an Avril Lavigneish ("Losing Grip") tone, but then her voice has this very druggy, drawn out drone. "Waste my tiiiiiime." Almost Courtney Love'ish?

Mordechai Shinefield (Mordy), Friday, 12 January 2007 03:51 (seventeen years ago) link

Only Radio Free Roscoe I ever saw was the episode featuring Skye Sweetnam as the BAD GIRL from out of town who makes a crazy video project (kinda like her homemade PR vids?) and writes ANARCHY RULES on the wall. (She also sings the theme song.)

nameom (nameom), Friday, 12 January 2007 04:00 (seventeen years ago) link

Also, never heard Aimee Allen before just now, but why hasn't John Mayer covered this song?? T-shirt: "I overslept the revolution"

nameom (nameom), Friday, 12 January 2007 04:09 (seventeen years ago) link

I only knew one actual teenager who watched The N. I imagine it's more prevalent in Canada. But when my wife and I were dating, we used to watch The N all the time on the dormitory television. Radio Free Roscoe, Daria and Degrassi. I think I watched Instant Star on my own.

Anyway, speaking of Charlotte, she says that 'Waste My Time' reminds her of Moby + Gwen Stefani doing 'South Side.' I hear what she means, in terms of Alexz Johnson's voice sounding like Gwen's in the chorus.

Mordechai Shinefield (Mordy), Friday, 12 January 2007 04:19 (seventeen years ago) link

I've watched Instant Star before, but like all the original programming on The N it doesn't really do anything for me. I didn't particuarly like any of the music although I admittedly heard little. The main reason why I have disliked The N shows is their over earnestness and seriousness, but if Mordechai says that RFR is cute then maybe I'll check it out. Then again, maybe I'll just stick to "Unfabulous", "Darcy's Wild Life", et al.

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Friday, 12 January 2007 04:41 (seventeen years ago) link

My daughter likes The N just fine.

Haikunym (Haikunym), Friday, 12 January 2007 05:21 (seventeen years ago) link

Greg, RFR is gonna be really easy to find. Apparently all the episodes are up on Youtube. It's less saccharine than Disney, but sweeter than DeGrassi. We used to love it.

Mordechai Shinefield (Mordy), Friday, 12 January 2007 06:54 (seventeen years ago) link

I saw some of Instant Star on Viva (Swiss music channel) this summer and thought it was thoroughly enjoyable, if completely stupid. It also has a great message regarding someone who wants to be a serious'n'credible rockstar having to take a lot of advice from an ex-boyband member and understand that you don't have to be Sonic Youth to make good music etc.

Most of the music on the first series (which is all I've seen any of) is ace, especially '24 Hours.' Some of it is hilarious. There's a fourth series coming out soon I believe.

Hazel Robinson (Moggy), Friday, 12 January 2007 08:16 (seventeen years ago) link

Drew Seeley wrote most of the songs for and did most of Zac Efron's singing on High School Musical

Not really; he only wrote "Getcha Head In The Game," which was more a group song with (if I recall correctly) Corbin Bleu rather than Zac leading the singing; and the version that got airplay was B5's. Seeley did sing on all the Zac Efron songs, but what I read in Billborad was that Zac sang when the register was low enough but Drew did all the high register lines. So Drew's the one who's soaring and flying. Drew rather than Zac performed at the HSM show in Madison Square Garden.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Friday, 12 January 2007 22:46 (seventeen years ago) link

But while we're on the subject:

Matthew Gerrard and Robbie Nevil: s/d and c/d.

They often write as a team, with Gerrard usually handling the production. They did two of the most popular tracks from HSM ("Start of Something New" and "We're All In This Together") and a whole bunch of the tracks on Cheetah Girls 2, which I saw last night. The thing is, their tracks are usually the ones I like least. My favorite song on HSM is "Breaking Free" by Jamie Houston, the two somewhat good Cheetah Girls singles are "Strut" and "Amigas Cheetahs," also by Jamie Houston. "Dance With Me" is on the soundtrack but performed by Drew Seeley and Belinda and written by Ray Cham (who cowrote "Getcha Head In The Game") and Charlene Licera, is heard in the film as a track that Sabrina and the teen count dance to.

But Gerrard actually has one of the better tracks (and one of the not better tracks) on the Vanessa Hudgens album, a good, somewhat dark-sounding dance track appropriately called "Let's Dance," and he co-wrote "The High Road," which is a nice (though below average for that very good album) track on JoJo's The High Road. (Crucial credit on that track, however, might be Jonathon "J.R." Rotem, who wrote and produced LeToya's really good "All Eyes On Me.") Gerrard also cowrote (w/ Avril Lavigne) Kelly Clarkson's "Breakaway," which is a good song despite having a line about spreading one's wings (but again overshadowed by other stuff on the album). Also wrote an unheard-by-me Lindsay Lohan track on the soundtrack to Confessions of a Teen Drama Queen, and one of my least favorite Hilary Duff singles ("Why Not"). He has something to do with the Bratz. And a lot more, I'm sure. Robbie Nevil had success as a singer in the late '80s, early '90s.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Friday, 12 January 2007 23:16 (seventeen years ago) link

Speaking of Cheetah Girls 2, I don't think any Cheetah is a great singer, but really they're not godawful, just dull. And "Strut" and "Amigas Cheetahs" are good r&b/Latin tracks, quite serviceable. The script seemed far clumsier than High School Musical's not-so-unclumsy script, just no deftness in its storytelling (I know it's trying to be comprehensible to eight-year-olds, but lots of books and movies also make themselves comprehensible to eight-year-olds without constant exposition in the dialogue); the dancing and colors were quite wonderful and compensated somewhat for the plot. Also, there was simply nothing as compelling as the teen culture subclashes in High School Musical, and the Cheetah climax - We're Singing Onstage When It Looked Like We Weren't Going To Be Allowed To - is empty in comparison to "Breaking Free" in HSM, which felt electric and served as a revelation to Troy's and Gabriela's friends: Like, We Get It, This Is What It's About, And These Two Are Actually Good! I thought Raven-Symoné was believably bossy as the bossy Galleria, and Sabrina Bryan was heartwarmingly warm being sweet, insecure, and lovestruck. And I managed to cry during the reconciliation scene between the Adrienne Bailon character and her mom's fiancé. But I have a talent for crying at movies. I thought the onscreen rapport between Adrienne and Raven-Symoné was about as good as the offscreen rapport. Kiely just seemed kinda there and nothing more. Guest singer Belinda Peregrin, who could sing the Cheetahs off the stage if she wanted to, didn't have much to do other than to look slightly perturbed by her domineering stage mom's machinations and to look pretty and guilty (and pretty guilty) by what she was doing to the Cheetahs. It's not a good movie, but I didn't regret the time spent watching it, and as I said, the colors and dancing are their own message.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Saturday, 13 January 2007 00:17 (seventeen years ago) link

I rather don't like "Let's Dance" OR "Never Underestimate A Girl", so that makes me agree with you even more. On the subject of Vanessa, I still found this to be the best of the direct Disney tie in actress albums of last year. My faves on V are "Say OK" by Anthor Birgisson/Savan Kotecha and "Let Go" by Bojanic/Hooper/Levan, whoever they are. The power ballad "Afraid" is also rather nice.

I wasn't a fan of Cheetah Girls 2 either, Frank. Still, it was better than the original.

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Saturday, 13 January 2007 01:54 (seventeen years ago) link

Jamie Huston's other credit I know of off the top of my head is on the Lucy Woodward album, but that didn't make a huge impression. If he wrote the song "Drama Queen," that's probably a tally in favor. Great (d-u-m) mid-song "rap" breakdown:

Life is a work of art/ You gotta paint it colorful,
Can make it anything U want/ Don't have to stick to any rules
You don't need a high IQ/ To succeed in what you do,
You just gotta have no doubt/ Just believe in yourself.

(Nope, Gerrard wrote a different one. Jamie Huston is on this soundtrack, too, wrote "A Day in the Life" which I haven't heard)

nameom (nameom), Saturday, 13 January 2007 02:04 (seventeen years ago) link

Then again, with all the anti-Gerrard talk in here, Gerrard/Nevil did write some really good Hannah Montana songs: "The Best of Both Worlds" and "Who Said". They also wrote the mediocre-to-average "The Other Side Of Me".

And Jamie Houston wrote "Pumpin Up The Party" which is almost inarguably her worst song (at least, as far as I am concerned). So Hannah Montana turns the Disney world UPSIDE DOWN.

Then again "J. Lurie" (acc to Allmusic) has cowriting credit on my two favorite Hannah Montana songs, "I Got Nerve" and "This Is The Life". F. Lurie is cowriter on "If We Were a Movie"

Whoops, I take back what I said about V above. It's a good album, but I definitely like the Hannah Montana OST more. Neither are top 20 albums of the year.

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Saturday, 13 January 2007 04:00 (seventeen years ago) link

Frank did you see Camp?

Tim Finney (Tim Finney), Saturday, 13 January 2007 05:06 (seventeen years ago) link

Just watched the "Drama Queen" vid for the first time...basically these different Lindsay characters are auditioning for some school production (proto-HSM), and each character takes the mic from the other ones (slinky red dress, trendy track suit and baseball cap, etc.) and there's a great moment where LL (in track suit, doing the sing/speak part) cracks up during the "Just believe in yourself" line, tosses the mic on the ground, and walks away. Judges' reaction: WTF?

nameom (nameom), Saturday, 13 January 2007 15:03 (seventeen years ago) link

(Wait, that's more like a trucker's hat, not baseball cap.)

A few recent articles about the HSM concert tour: One pretty good on Tom Breihan's VV blog, one not so good from NYT.

nameom (nameom), Saturday, 13 January 2007 21:12 (seventeen years ago) link

Continuing on w/ the Diz songwriter theme, watched Jump In tonight, it was pretty good.

"Jump to the Rhythm" was by Robyn Johnson and Frank Fitzpatrick, not her normal songwriters, and nobody I've heard of.

Jamie Houston did "Vertical" which is kinda mediocre.

Gerrard/Nevil did "Push It to the Limit" and that Keke Palmer song which name I forget, which are the two pretty good songs from the movie. I'm starting to kinda like "Push It to the Limit", after initially hating it.

On another note, I'm not digging Ashley Tisdale's singles very much. "He Said, She Said" is OK, but I'm not into "Be Good To Me" (and does anybody know the songwriters on that?). Course I might change my mind on this, but neither is really grabbing me.

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Sunday, 14 January 2007 04:47 (seventeen years ago) link

Definitely JoJo, how old is she now anyway?

Luke Slater (Alan Bean), Sunday, 14 January 2007 10:57 (seventeen years ago) link

Proof that teenpop has too many guitars: Rose Falcon and dad Billy on stage with the Mulch Brothers and Richie Sambora.

nameom (nameom), Sunday, 14 January 2007 17:24 (seventeen years ago) link

Also got B.G. Tha Heart of tha Streetz Vol. 1. As with the other two CDs, I'll report on whether the vocalist on this one most resembles Lacey or Marit.

This is from one of Frank's posts on last year's thread. Just mentioning it because according to my Pandora station, it counts as teenpop! Updating it today, they've added a lot of artists recently. They even have Leslie Carter's "Like Wow!" and Daphne & Celeste's "U.G.L.Y." but no other D&C.

nameom (nameom), Sunday, 14 January 2007 20:05 (seventeen years ago) link

I'm gonna stick up for Duff's "Why Not," which is probably my favorite Duff song.

Does Bextor count as teen pop, or is she now artpop like Kylie?

Matthew E. Armstrong (gensu3k1), Sunday, 14 January 2007 20:17 (seventeen years ago) link

Another tally in Gerrard's favor, Hayden Paniettiere's good track, "Your New Girlfriend," from Girl Next. That's Britney's sis Jamie in the photo montage, no teenpop (music) career to speak of yet except the theme song.

Aliana Lohan released her Xmas album while ILM was down and it's...pretty strange. Video for second-most-resoundingly-"kicked"-on-RD-last-year single (don't know which was #1) "Christmas Magic" is actually kinda disturbing, watch for the weirdly sinister reindeer and snowman at the end that coulda been stand-ins for the dog-suit guy in The Shining. More interesting/WTF is "Lohan Holiday" feat. Lindsay somewhere in the background (I think?), available here.

nameom (nameom), Sunday, 14 January 2007 20:39 (seventeen years ago) link

Apart from "Lohan Holiday" that Ali Lohan album is absolutely horrible. And even "Lohan Holiday" isn't so great, though it is pretty good, at least it has a discernable melodic hook. Lyrics are a real headscratcher though. Wasn't it "I Like Christmas" that got booted from RD, though? I might be misremembering.

I listened to/reviewed a whole boatload of teenpop Christmas songs this December. Here are links to some of the more notable ones:

Hilary Duff - "Santa Claus Lane"; Hilary Duff - "What Christmas Should Be"; Christina Aguilera - "Christmas Time"; Mariah Carey - "Miss You Most at Christmastime" (presumably you all know "All I Want For Christmas Is You" already, so I won't take the time to get a link); Cheetah Girls - "Five More Days Til Christmas" (This is the best Cheetahs songs that I've heard - er, sorry about the sound quality though); 'N Sync - "Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays"; S Club 7 - "Perfect Christmas". Those are all the songs that I reviewed that are worth listening that I could find on YouTube.

I wasn't a big fan of Hannah Montana's "Rocking Around the Christmas Tree", as I found that her voice didn't work well for the rocking tune they were going for. Maybe after she matures and her voice fills out more she'll be able to pull that stuff off, but right now it didn't sound great. Jordan Pruitt had a Christmas song too, and it was a really good little tune called "Santa Don't Stop", but for the life of me I can't find a free version for listening anywhere online.

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Sunday, 14 January 2007 21:56 (seventeen years ago) link

Worth mentioning on Ali Lohan's album is a song called "Santa's Reindeer Ride", a cover of an early Amy Grant tune. Apparently, what they did is they just took the old Amy Grant song and digitally added Ali's vocals to it. Bleh, not that great of a song to start with, and Ali's vocals are way worse than Amy Grant's so the final result is not pretty.

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Sunday, 14 January 2007 22:00 (seventeen years ago) link

Newest Amy Diamond single from her Still Me, Still Now album is "It Can Only Get Better". Gone is the reggae beat, this is a fairly generic sounding pop ballad backed with piano. The lyrics are still way too old for her, and she's still a great singer though. It's a really pretty song and I like it a lot. Kinda makes me tear up a bit. Can't help but think that "Don't Lose Any Sleep Over You" or "That's Life" would be better choices for a single though. Get this album a US release stat.

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Sunday, 14 January 2007 22:06 (seventeen years ago) link

Finally got to hear some of Vanessa Hudgens music. It's well produced, but I can't say I hear the same personality in it as I do in Duff, Aly & AJ, Hannah, or even Tisdale. And there seems to be an attempt to sell her in two directions at the same time - Blender used the word "sultry" to describe her, qualifying it moments after by explaining that she's 18. That fits into the Britney, Christina Disney paradigm - where that sexual discovery/playfulness is apart of the draw (like in Vanessa's "Come Back to Me"). The second is what HSM is, and what Vanessa's songs on HSM are - innocent, romantic, highschoolish. The double selling is odd - I feel really ambiguous about her, while Tisdale with weaker tracks I find interesting.

Anyway: Was this album in production during HSM? And is it a Disney album? Who is writing the songs? I'm curious if this is a product of her (her manager, whatever) impetus V. the Disney machine's. Obviously for each of these Disney stars there's a point where they have to distinguish themselves from Disney - but I hadn't heard anything about Hudgens before HSM, so this sudden departure from the script feels... well... scripted.

Mordechai Shinefield (Mordy), Monday, 15 January 2007 04:48 (seventeen years ago) link

Can't say that I'm feeling anything sultry in Vanessa Hudgens. I'm coming to like "Come Back To Me" more; but her small voice is just kinda small (rather than expressively small à la Robyn or Hilary); there's a potential whine or wail that could take her in the direction of Angel Sabatar of the (definitely sultry) Cover Girls, once the whine/wail gets deeper and richer. That's probably too much to hope for. The album is likable second-rank r&b; on Disney-affiliated Hollywood Records. The songs I like are "Come Back To Me" (written and produced by Antonina Armato and Tim James, known in these parts as Aly & AJ's collaborators on "Chemicals React," "Shine," "Greatest Time Of Year," and "Not This Year," which is interesting because those are all arranged with power chords, not with "Come Back To Me"'s r&b beats; the pair also worked with Hoku back in 2000); "Let Go" and "Rather Be With You" (by Andrew Bojanic and Liz Hooper, a couple of protegés of the Matrix, transplanted Aussies, produce under the moniker Wizardz of Oz; also involved in Christian music); "Say OK" (by Anthor* Birgisson Savan Kotecha, who work for Maratone (Max Martin's production outfit)), "Let's Dance" (by Jonas Jeberg, Bridget Benenate, Matthew Gerard, with Gerrard on the dials; he's worked with Benenate a lot); and "Whatever Will Be" (by Carl Falk, Savan Kotecha, Jake Shultze). Leah Haywood and Dan James, who worked with Aly & A.J. on the great "Rush," have material here that's disappointing (Shelly Pelkin who cowrote Ashlee's great "Love Me For Me," had a hand in one of those)).

*Also seen him spelled "Arnthor."

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 15 January 2007 06:54 (seventeen years ago) link

I figure one of you pedos will get a hard-on over this.

Kidz Bop - "Chicken Noodle Soup"
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bjr-bP-sSgs

(I jest. It's cute.)

The Reverend Rodney J. Greene is false metal! (R. J. Greene), Monday, 15 January 2007 07:01 (seventeen years ago) link

Actually like the two Aliana Lohan tracks I've heard, "Lohan Christmas" and "Christmas Magic," though both sound Adult Contemporary as of 30 years ago rather than what's been marketed recently as teenpop, and Aliana's phrasing doesn't quite sound American, which is strange. I don't really have an opinion of her voice, beyond that.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 15 January 2007 07:02 (seventeen years ago) link

I was using "sultry" only to show how she's being perceived - I agree with you that she doesn't come off as particularly sultry (assuming that the adjective can describe a way you use your voice -- considering I'm listening to Donna Summer right now: Love to Love You Baby is sultry). But I think she's trying to play in a certain way that has you describe it as "likable second-rank r&b" where I don't think you'd ever call Aly & AJ that (despite the similar producers). Or to put in better words, my sister loves Aly + AJ, but I don't think she'd get Hudgens. One of my old roommates, who loved r&b (second-rank or otherwise, he wasn't particular about the quality), would love Hudgens, but wouldn't get Aly + AJ.

Mordechai Shinefield (Mordy), Monday, 15 January 2007 07:15 (seventeen years ago) link

Btw: When I make that distinction between Aly/AJ and Hudgens, I'm referring to album-Hudgens, not HSM-Hudgens (if that wasn't clear).

Also, Frank, rereading your initial post in this thread (looking for a possible comment on Hudgens) I noticed you said: "Teen newbie Taylor Swift is on the country stations with teen confessional sounds and concerns and may have the talent to match Aly & A.J. if not Ashlee (yet)."

What I heard from Swift makes this statement really confusing. Obviously you aren't comparing styles, or genres (or even a vocal comparison)... is it just the confessional style?

Mordechai Shinefield (Mordy), Monday, 15 January 2007 07:19 (seventeen years ago) link

Tim, I haven't seen Camp.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 15 January 2007 07:28 (seventeen years ago) link

FWIW I've listened to "Lohan Holiday" about ten or fifteen times today, just bought the album, too.

Now that you mention it, her voice strikes me as almost having some of Amy Diamond's phrasing/affectation, the obvious difference being that Ali's way way more subdued (but not bad). I just can't imagine what the general idea behind this production was, since it doesn't seem to be in conversation with any recent music, teenpop or otherwise (maybe background music in a Hallmark commercial, but I bet even Hallmark's moved on to indie rock by now). Do keyboards even have those synth presets anymore? Ditto the costumes in that video...were those all lying around in some wardrobe closet somewhere near the shoot, or did someone actually design them?

(It was "I Like Christmas" that got kicked, can't find the number one most hated of the year yet.)

nameom (nameom), Monday, 15 January 2007 07:30 (seventeen years ago) link

Mordechai, check out "A Place in This World," which has an almost 100% teen confessional chorus. Pretty sure the chord progression is identical to "Behind These Hazel Eyes" (Frank first pointed this out).

nameom (nameom), Monday, 15 January 2007 07:34 (seventeen years ago) link

It's got the same tension as an Aly and AJ track, too, plays around with resolving to major with the emphasis on the relative minor (vi-IV-I(/wind at back marker)-V). Difference being that Aly and AJ would never resolve to the major root in the verse (as Taylor does, and the mood lightens up), they'd go right back to the relative minor and keep the tension bubbling under the surface.

nameom (nameom), Monday, 15 January 2007 07:47 (seventeen years ago) link

Thanks - I can completely hear the confessional thing in A Place In This World. I'm not sure I hear the same kind of thing in Aly + AJ, but I do hear it in Clarkson, or Ashlee. That said, the rest I've heard of the album seems to be a willful evocation of Tim McGraw (as the song overtly points out). Thing about Aly and AJ is I don't hear confessional in their music - I'm sure it could be pointed out, but that's not what I'm left with. I'm left with breathless articulation - not self-reflective.

Mordechai Shinefield (Mordy), Monday, 15 January 2007 07:50 (seventeen years ago) link

xpost

Mordy - Taylor does softer rock than Ashlee or Aly & A.J. or Kelly, but some of her songs make her emotional growth and personal experiences the issue; e.g., "A Place In This World" starts off, "I don't know what I want, so don't ask me/'Cause I'm still trying to figure it out/Don't know what's down this road, I'm just walking/Trying to see through the rain coming down/Even though I'm not the only one/Who feels the way I do." And the chorus - its melody and harmony - runs very close to "Behind These Hazel Eyes." Her vocal twang and the banjo or mandolin running through the chorus of "Should've Said No" doesn't make it any less a wailing rockin' teen rager on the order of Ashlee's "I Am Me." And "Tim McGraw" has smart smart smart lyrics. Not that there's no precedence for this in country: Deana Carter is a singer-songwriter precursor. (Not an age thing; Deana was already in her 30s before she hit with "Strawberry Wine." "Tim McGraw" is a variation on the first-love reminiscence of "Strawberry Wine." Strange that young Taylor is doing a reminiscence song. Also strange that the lyrics may be better than those in any of the hundred other first-love reminiscence songs in country since "Strawberry Wine.") I'll see if I can hunt down some of my December posts on Taylor from the ad hoc rolling country-in-email-exile substitution for a thread.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 15 January 2007 07:58 (seventeen years ago) link

(Deana didn't write "Strawberry Wine," but she wrote everything on 2005's Story Of My Life, which does a good job of melding country narrative songs and singer-songwriter personal songs. And "The Girl You Left Me For" has as many "yeah yeah yeahs" as Aly & A.J.'s "Rush.")

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 15 January 2007 08:08 (seventeen years ago) link

In last year's thread we had a discussion of how you don't actually have to confess anything to be "confessional." (This was in regard to Michelle Branch.) But I'd say Aly & A.J.'s "Not This Year" and "Sticks And Stones" qualify as A Girl's Personal Feelings. Though if Aly & A.J. were screaming their throats out those'd be punk. Sound has a lot to do with whether you're perceived as "confessional." We've been using "confessional" as a vague shorthand for a bunch of things. I'm not in particular trying to tie Taylor to the Michalka girls in any way that's deeper than they're being teens who are somewhat within musical range of each other and whose minds are at work.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 15 January 2007 08:20 (seventeen years ago) link

Could somebody who likes the Ali Lohan record explain why then? I'll listen to it again when I get home to see if I missed anything, but on first listen I thought it was awful. Except for "Lohan Holiday", like I said.

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Monday, 15 January 2007 13:23 (seventeen years ago) link

'lohan holiday' is awful! so awful it's compelling admittedly but still.

the jojo album is VERY good, having listened to it all weekend...

lex pretend (lex pretend), Monday, 15 January 2007 13:33 (seventeen years ago) link

So, can one of the Brits out there explain why Amy Winehouse (whose album comes out in the States in March) is something more than, like, the new Des'ree or Dionne Farris or something? I mean, I get it, I think: "Authentic soul" tedium for grownups with "good taste", and her single is about not being able to stop drinking or taking drugs, apparently, so that makes her Billie Holiday. And what makes her authentic is that her singing strains all the life out, so see, she's obviously on her last legs and therefore highly moving. Why should I care? I couldn't get through four songs on the CD yesterday.

xhuxk (xheddy), Monday, 15 January 2007 14:35 (seventeen years ago) link


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.