When did Doom Metal/Black Metal and the like become "hip" and why?

when I was an angsty teen, I definitely felt like there was a punk - metal divide, and on the punk side, it was acceptable to like new wave, goth, industrial - but metal was a different clubhouse.

xp alan: exactly. metal is/was a safe place for a v particular kind of teenage (<--- important!) weirdo.

that also was on the football team - from my experience.

If BM and Doom were really hip then why aren't the xx loving hipsters posting here saying how they love it? ;)

are there hipsters on ilx?

honestly a big part of why i didn't get into metal sooner (i was weaned on hard rock, ffs, the progression would have been a natural one) is because, in the middle american high school, listening to metal meant buying into a lot of other stuff (imo at the time). whereas a person could listen to ANYTHING else with the same enthusiasm and not have to buy a bunch of black t-shirts.

If BM and Doom were really hip then why aren't the xx loving hipsters posting here saying how they love it? ;)

― Pfunkboy : The Dronelord vs The Girly Metal Daleks (Herman G. Neuname), Friday, December 11, 2009 1:34 PM (2 minutes ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

i know you're kidding and that this is obvious, but: more actual metalheads think thoughts like this about pussy indies than whatever the inverse would be.

(at least that's how i envision the universe)

goths bought a bunch of black t-shirts, too.

If I had liked & let it be known that I liked metal during High School, I would have run a serious risk of getting beat up for it-- by the metalheads.

^^^

goths didn't do much beating up of people.

As it was I only had to be verbally harassed for having spiked hair and wearing 'The Roar Of The Masses Could Be Farts' T-shirt.

i mean, not ~really~, but when i was in high school a lot of the metalheads were kinda hesh-y

what is "hesh-y"?

i know you're kidding and that this is obvious, but: more actual metalheads think thoughts like this about pussy indies than whatever the inverse would be.

Actual metalheads think about the scorching flames of HELL!

the quality of being like a hesher

yeah, but what does that mean?

i know you're kidding and that this is obvious, but: more actual metalheads think thoughts like this about pussy indies than whatever the inverse would be.

I take it you mean indiekids ignore and look down on metal mostly? I'm sure that's mostly true but it wasnt always the case during the grunge years. OK that might just have been UK/Europe as im well aware metal was a really bad word during the 90s hence the need for the prefix for Nu-Metal - signifying it had nothing to do with metals past. (bizarrely of course Nu-Metal was created by UK magazine Kerrang)
But anyway for a brief period in the early 90s indiekids here who read NME/MM listened to Alice In Chains,Pearl Jam,Soundgarden,Smashing Pumpkins,RATM,RHCP etc when they wouldn't previously go near "heavy" bands.
Maybe (older) hipsters liking doom/BM does come from growing up with grunge? Melvins for instance are loved by both camps.

i know you're kidding and that this is obvious, but: more actual metalheads think thoughts like this about pussy indies than whatever the inverse would be.

Actual metalheads think about the scorching flames of HELL!

Oh and a lot of people got into doom via stoner rock which was kinda at its most hip in the late 90s, which clearly came partly from grunge.

yeah, but what does that mean?

A hesher is but a worm. A worm who tries to make himself metal in the aluminum of a beer can, in the copper buttons of a denim jacket, in the steel of a muscle car.

xp: re: hesher:
like a townie ... outer-suburbs lower-working-class
like the white folks you see on Cops. basically the Coastal version of a redneck

and as i said earlier, an awful lot of people crossed over to doom/BM via "folk" like dead raven choir/wolfmangler. Those certainly changed my mind about BM(along with hearing Weakling because i liked The Fucking Champs, obv i was already long into doom.

some of us are older than the generation that "grew up" with grunge. We grew up when hair metal was on the charts in the US, and equating that with "metal" could easily put someone who would appreciate Darkthrone, Napalm Death, black metal, death metal, doom metal, what have you, off the general category.

I would say Melvins are the white elephant in the room here.

^^^ xp to sarahel

anyway my present liking of metal is really just me picking back up the trail that I veered off from when I got my first Huskers, Minutemen, Black Flag and Pups records. The year before that, my favorite shit had been stuff like Blue Oyster Cult, Molly Hatchet, Aqualung and Twisted Sister, yr basic hard rock diet that would have surely led to NWOBHM and thrash if those options weren't physically dangerous in that environment.

(tho i'm not even 30 yet)

xp - sexydancer - I'd only heard the term once before from someone that grew up in Washington State, and I was confused about what she was referring to. I'm just wondering whether it's specific to a particular region, or whether I just happened to grow up in a region where this term wasn't used.

honestly, i'm kinda using the term retrospectively---not sure if i heard it before going to lol college in NE

I never heard hesher till after I left minnesota in 1989.

wait, no, i did: in the pages of POWDER magazine, haw

New England or Nebraska?

but once i pulled what the word meant from the context, i was like 'ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh i know that guy'

xp i am also a despicable ivy, sarahel

they talk funny in that part of the country.

There was only a couple of people i knew at school that was into metal (same goes for "indie" most were into U2/INXS/Guns n Roses/Bon Jovi/Pet Shop Boys/Erasure/Queen/Dire Straits and whatever was in the charts in the mid to late 80s) Only a couple were into hair metal, a few others liked Slayer,Megadeth etc. I think i was put off metal as i hated hair metal.
I had a cd player n stuff but i wasnt "into" music. I occasionally listed to peel or tommy vance just to hear something that i wasnt fed up with hearing, and i also liked some classic bands like the stones,sex pistols and the like but actually "getting right into music" that didn't happen til Nirvana, that opened up a whole new world of music that I had no idea that existed really.

I do know that in the 90s playgrounds in the high schools round here got divided into "the rockers/metallers" and "the beautiful people" who were into mainstream chart stuff (which includes club stuff.) No idea what it's like now, but emo's seem to be as popular as nu metal/goth was.

xp: I'm from Washington too, and remember "hesher" being thrown around in the late 80s-early 90s to describe "metalheads" or people who resembled Cliff Burton.

The year before that, my favorite shit had been stuff like Blue Oyster Cult, Molly Hatchet, Aqualung and Twisted Sister, yr basic hard rock diet that would have surely led to NWOBHM and thrash if those options weren't physically dangerous in that environment.

― vadnais heights is cougartown (Jon Lewis), Friday, December 11, 2009 1:50 PM (5 minutes ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

"physically dangerous" overstates the case in my own experience, but this is basically OTM. I listened exclusively to KQ and 93X. i would've continued to do so were it not for two major radio events: 93X became the EDGE, and REV105 happened.

yeah - from kingkonggodzilla's evocative description, I can definitely say I went to high school with a number of dudes like that.

The metal dudes were the only (non-ethnically determined) outsider group at my St. Paul high school besides the punk rockers. The only proto-goths I knew were from the suburbs. There were like 2 New Romantics.

wait gbx you are also from twin cities (KQ)?

some of us are older than the generation that "grew up" with grunge.

well i was 18 when grunge hit, but like i said, i wasnt really "into" music til then.
I guess i grew up with hair metal but i hated it, but it was a lot easier to ignore/be unaware in the uk. It's not like those bands got top 10 hits ,got played on radio and most people did not have access to MTV. Guns n Roses were the exception. I wouldn't really have been aware of hair metal if one of my best mates kept buying it.

1990s Olympia WA had a generation of Melvins-obsessed "hipsters" (or riot-boys or Nu Punkers) ... Karp, Mukelteo Fairies, Behold the Prophet No Lord Shall Live, Fucking Champs, etc

Honest answer:

Pretty sure the whole current dilletante/hipster/indierock embrace of black metal/doom/kvlt started with Dave Grohl doing the Probot record on Southern Lord which gave them instant cred among dorkus Sufjan losers and a much bigger budget to actually promote stuff like Sunn, Earth, and get records like that serviced to indie rock writers by indie publicists and whatnot

I'm pretty sure it started before that. Grohl was probably doing it to ride along on it's wave. That record truly flopped though, so it didn't do him or anyone involved much good.

JL: yeah, live in MPLS through 3rd grade, out to h4stings for high school. away to the east coast for college, several years in the west/chicago, back in mpls

current status: hungry, poser

don't forget JOHN ZZZORN dude

he attracted a different kind of dilettante/hipster than the ones Whiney is describing.

we are talking historical hipsters tho.