Year-End Critics' Polls 2013

yeah - plus, most years i have a rock solid top 5-6 and then about 15-20 that are all around the same place in my estimation, and hard to rank against each other. every top 10 i've submitted this year has had a different 8/9/10

Ha, same here. First Julia Holter pushed out Run the Jewels, now Ka has ousted Holter. Even my top 5 has moved about a bit from publication to publication.

with tracks it's even more pronounced, i have like two immovables at 1 and 2 and then about 50 interchangeable and equally amazing contenders

my 8-10 albums is basically a revolving door between creep, 2 chainz, holden, amel larrieux, floorplan, ciara, quadron and sky ferreira, idk how to get eight albums into three spare spots

I've got a list as long as my arm of wildly divergent albums to investigate from these lists.

Yeah, the echo-chamber idea is old news, but I'm not sure the answer is databased theory (whatever that is).

Maybe this is somewhat specific to my own experience of the web over the past 18 months as well, I've found myself continuously binging on RSS feeds and bouncing across different sites, then seeing the same records covered across different locations unfolding almost in real time. Is this how traders feel when they're following the market or something? It's a fairly bad experience for sustained reading, for sure - since it easily lends itself to continual partial awareness and scanning.

Anyway, I think it's time to cut back my info-consumption for a New Years' resolution. Change my habits, go on a diet. I've gotten back into buying the Wire in print actually, and have mostly been enjoying that format.

Here's the Crack list:

http://crackmagazine.net/music/albums-of-the-year-10-1/

We've gone for...KURT VILE at AOTY.

MikoMcha, you might enjoy Clay Johnson's book. It recommends exactly that.

Yeah, have seen that around. I don't know if I can bring myself to read a self-help guide published by O'Reilly! Is there more to it than what's on the cover?

finally listened to that Daniel Avery album properly and it didn't convince me it was offering much, even from a unabashedly nostalgic pov. kinda felt like a late 90s Glastonbury dance tent act, Salt Tank or The Drum Club or some second division stuff like that

There's not really a strong voting bloc for rock so I suspect albums I thought were obvious contenders, like Nick Cave, Arcade Fire and QOTSA, won't place in the top 40.

These are all total 'middling nth album' type picks, the sort of thing that's bound to be flushed out if you have a diverse and committed set of voters. I mean Yeezus is one of those as well but it's one with a bit of personality to go with its ridiculous peaks and troughs.

Yeah, the echo-chamber idea is old news, but I'm not sure the answer is databased theory (whatever that is)

I think he means it's impossible to tell whether these lists really are getting any more or less PR-driven or uniform without actually looking at the data and seeing if it supports that. My guess = yes, mildly, but only because there are WAY more lists than there used to be and the internet has knocked down a lot of the geographical boundaries and biases that used to exist in critical spheres (a mid-90s US rock mag list would have looked VERY different to a UK one).

kinda felt like a late 90s Glastonbury dance tent act

This is an excellent way of putting it.

Oh snap I should've voted for something from Timberlake

Is there more to it than what's on the cover?

xpost to DL - Haim was No 12.

. . . the overdiscussed dance music revival finally codified itself into a new conformity: abrasive, conceptual techno

I'm not remotely an expert, but pretty much none of the dance music I've been listening to from this year sounds like that.

yeah i mean this exists, but if you choose to ignore all other kinds of dance music of course it's going to feel like that. i get the feeling this whole Britt argument stems from having a very selective worldview anyway.

complicating factor re: consensus: music writers are inherently biased toward listening to albums they think they can get paid for.

http://www.afribizcharts.com/top100.php

Stuff on this list is not marketed much to American music crits (or others)

That's a flawed (leaves out sales in numerous countries) biz sales chart but it includes some interesting songs

Last Rites posted their top 25 metal albums:

http://lastrit.es/articles/654/the-last-rites-top-25

The Guardian wont ever do that EZ. Their writers and readers look down on it.

hmm?

except for Dom Lawson obviously

Pimp themselves? Is that it? Because let me tell you, my ballot did not effect much on that list.

Nice to see Summoning on that list!

no no no, Im jusy saying that you will never see a metal list on the guardian. You wont even see it represented in their eoy poll. Places like that usually have a token entry at best. They're as bad as every other site for ignoring certain genres.

I can't deny that and I'm as guilty as anyone apart from Dom. I find metal utterly alienating, sorry.

xp

Well my mind doesn't grade music numerically so lists are a waste of time and space as a rule, filed away next to games of "Babe or Minger", but it is nice to see "oh cool we listen to a lot of the same records"
― fear of zing failure

This misses the point. If you only focus on the top 3-10 on the lists you'd get the illusion that people listen to the same stuff, but it's just not true. Despite ballots being limited to a measly 10, Pazz & Jop for example usually has a couple thousand albums. If the ballot were expanded, it would probably get near 10,000, with more varied results near the top too. I always thought these lists were an opportunity to check out stuff you didn't discover yourself previously. I guess some people just aren't interested in that.

xxp I agree it would be great to have a weekly digest of the best articles, think pieces, reviews and interviews from music sites for Kindle. I have cheap Kindle subscriptions to Pop Matters and The Onion, but lately they've been excluding the music pieces, argh!

Is a Whiney doing his noise list for Spin before he goes?

no worries DL its not a personal attack on you or anyone. I get the feeling the Guardian would be like that whoever they employed but its not just the guardian anyway.

In terms of features, the Guardian does more metal than any of the other UK broadsheets, and more reviews, too. But it's a fight to convince print section editors that they should carry it. I've been able to get "classic" metal in; I've been able to get some young Brit metal in; when I was editing Film&Music, we covered a fair bit. But people who have no interest in metal require a big sell: "They burn churches1" or "They worship Satan!" or "They're the wildest band in the world." Saying: "Metal people think this band is really important" doesn't cut it. Sadly.

But people who have no interest in metal require a big sell: "They burn churches1" or "They worship Satan!" or "They're the wildest band in the world."

That's pretty sad & depressing actually :( Would have hoped The Guardian would be above such stereotypes. Imagine all music coverage was based on stereotypes?

All music coverage IS based on stereotypes.

Obviously I listen to a lot more than just metal but every year these lists that have the same top 10s practically ignore a LOT of what is going on.

xp

dan that is depressing then

my favorite discovery from these year-end lists are john wizards (tbh i think curmudgeon mentioned them to me right before i started seeing them in a ton of lists) - cannot stop listening

You could totally sell metal in the same way as jazz, avant and experimental music these days I reckon.

You could totally sell metal in the same way as jazz, avant and experimental music these days I reckon.

I'm kinda hoping the exact opposite is true, actually.

who is the current musician most likely to become the director of the future lincoln center metal orchestra?

Yngwie, of course.

Time Out Clubbing's top 10 tunes:

10: Breach - Jack
9: Paul Woolford - Untitled
8: Green Velvet - Bigger Than Prince
7. Sophie - Nothing More To Say
6. Doc Daneeka - Walk On It
5. Special Request - Ride
4. Joy Orbison - BRTHDTT
3. Duke Dumont ft. A*M*E - Need U 100% (Skream Remix)
2. Tessela - Hackney Parrot
1. Todd Terje - Strandbar

^^^ Now THAT'S a 2013 I actually recognise, and 0% abraisive, conceptual techno.

shudder

so glad to finally see a list correctly choose "nothing more to say" over "bipp"

Last Rites posted their top 25 metal albums:

http://lastrit.es/articles/654/the-last-rites-top-25

― EZ Snappin, Thursday, December 12, 2013 5:43 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

The Guardian wont ever do that EZ. Their writers and readers look down on it.

― pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Thursday, December 12, 2013 5:46 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

this exchange is puzzling me

Bipp is cute and fun but Nothing More To Say is is just a monster.

any excuse to get the hobby horse out of the stables xp

oh look, disclosure #6 in the guardian list

FACT's final 10 now up:

http://www.factmag.com/2013/12/09/the-50-best-albums-of-2013/42/

surprised (but pleased) to see sky at #2

The complete FACT list:
01. DEAN BLUNT - The Redeemer
02. SKY FERREIRA - Night Time, My Time
03. KANYE WEST - Yeezus
04. GALCHER LUSTWERK - 100% Galcher
05. KELELA - Cut 4 Me
06. STELLAR OM SOURCE - Joy One Mile
07. KEVIN GATES - The Luca Brasi Story
08. LIL UGLY MANE - Three-Sided Tape Vol. 1
09. DJ RASHAD - Rollin'
10. OMAR-S - Thank You For Letting Me Be Myself
11. KA - The Night's Gambit
12. JAI PAUL - Leaked Demos
13. LOGOS - Cold Mission
14. COLLEEN - The Weighing of the Heart
15. ROME FORTUNE - Beautiful Pimp
16. JAMES HOLDEN - The Inheritors
17. MUMDANCE - Twists and Turns
18. POWELL - Untitled
19. DJ MUSTARD - Ketchup
20. MSSINGNO - MssingNo
21. PRURIENT - Through The Window
22. THE HOUSE IN THE WOODS - Bucolica
23. CHANCE THE RAPPER - Acid Rap
24. GRUMBLING FUR - Glynnaestra
25. MGUN - The Near Future
26. SYCLOPS - A Blink Of An Eye
27. RON MORELLI - Spit
28. DANNY BROWN - Old
29. THESE NEW PURITANS - Field Of Reeds
30. EARL SWEATSHIRT - Doris
31. HUERCO S - Colonial Patterns
32. FKA TWIGS - EP2
33. ROLY PORTER - Life Cycle of a Massive Star
34. ONEOHTRIX POINT NEVER - R Plus Seven
35. MR MUTHAFUCKIN' EXQUIRE - Kismet
36. LAUREL HALO - Chance of Rain
37. TREE - Sunday School II: When Church Lets Out
38. DONATO DOZZY - Donato Dozzy Plays Bee Mask
39. KING LOUIE - Jeep Music
40. SUICIDEYEAR - Japan
41. CIARA - Ciara
42. DRAKE - Nothing Was The Same
43. VAKULA - You've Never Been To Konotop (Selected Works 2009-12)
44. FILTER DREAD - Space Loops
45. AUTRE NE VEUT - Anxiety
46. AUTECHRE - Exai
47. FRIENDZONE - DX
48. THE KNIFE - Shaking The Habitual
49. MILEY CYRUS - Bangerz
50. CREAM JUICE - Man Feelings

46. AUTECHRE - Exai
47. FRIENDZONE - DX
48. THE KNIFE - Shaking The Habitual
49. MILEY CYRUS - Bangerz
50. CREAM JUICE - Man Feelings

On paper this almost has its own narrative.