review of nominations and VOTING for (very nebulously defined) ELECTRONIC DANCE TRACKS of the 00s

Emmanuel Jal - Kuar (Henrik Schwarz Remix)

Pfft. Damn.

i am gonna set an arbitrary deadline at 50 ballots

"50 ballotz stands for 1 ballot from every state of the USA, all them ballotz would be stronger than every weapon, if they would be united - THUG LIFE"

so how many ballots are we at right now? also i wish that spotify thing worked where i live cos i'd love to hear all those nominated tracks i don't know !

youtube has a ton of them

they'll also be the ones that get most votes (mouth to mouth, orbitalife) - records that really blow up and then disappear, it isn't because they're no good its because they tend to dominate, and then disrupt the flow of a set once they get heard a lot

Both of these records are too recent though - you need about a 10yr period of grace before they start to reappear. FWIW I don't think either of these records are that great, nor will they appear particularly high up the poll (Mouth to Mouth might place somewhere, I doubt many ppl care that much about Orbitalife at this stage in the game).

i have 34 ballots at this point ... we're going to next sunday (one week extension) goal is 50 posts

"mouth to mouth" is placing pretty high on my ballot i think

though i prefer "mund zu mund" these days

mund zu mund is totally the superior, but tragically overlooked, younger sibling.

I figure there's also a bunch of sometime ILM posters who are authorities on the subject and whose contributions would be invaluable (e.g. d.l3one p.sh3rburne) but probably don't know this poll exists.

we gotta pound the pavement a bit, webmail the usual suspects

OTOH if they were interested in ILM you'd think they'd have seen it buy now

Both of these records are too recent though - you need about a 10yr period of grace before they start to reappear. FWIW I don't think either of these records are that great, nor will they appear particularly high up the poll (Mouth to Mouth might place somewhere, I doubt many ppl care that much about Orbitalife at this stage in the game).

but they are records that disappear is the point....not when they reappear, but the fact that they disappear

many votes on chart will be based on memories, mouth to mouth will place highly

prefer i speak for some of that

whereas a record like fifth element prob never got overplayed in same way and never really dropped away often hear that played out

I don't know why I'm the only one having trouble making sense of this:

over 1000 nominations

50 votes each

So in one ballot we should include as many nominations as we want (up to 1000)? And then we choose our top 50 from all of the nominations from everyone? Sorry for being dense.

we already nominated, just pick your 50 favorites and rank them

Pretty skimpy list :(

There are no entries matching high contrast

My fault for missing the nominations of course.

what if I ask pipecock to vote? I talk to him now and then.

think we can do without that, tbh

pipecock would have nominated some good records

tell him to send a ballot down the pipe

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zmAlkUpZPRI

wrong one,

here he is!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=usccACkIxxs

Who was Pipecock again? I remember the name being mentioned a few years ago, but I've no idea why his opinion is so important?

He's a resident advisor writer, blogger and DJ who is known for his strong support of American artists and labels like Omar S, Jus Ed, FXHE and Underground quality. He was always the nicest poster and was banned for an argument with Local Garda that got a little too personal.

Wasn't always, man I'm bad with the typoes lately.

A lot of the music Pipecock rates is great, but his Internet persona really grates as he seems to instinctively dismiss a lot of music because it doesn't fit into his rules. He's probably popped up on all forums at some point, posted for a while, got into a fight with some regulars and then left.

in short, he's a purist of the highest order.

is it too late to vote

nope.

how long do I have

i have 34 ballots at this point ... we're going to next sunday (one week extension) goal is 50 posts

"mouth to mouth" is placing pretty high on my ballot i think

― the late great, Monday, June 4, 2012 8:25 PM (2 days ago) Bookmark

So you have until Sunday Late Great's time. Don't know that means in Hawaii-land.

only 3 hours difference (2 in the winter)

I have no right to complain, as I didn't take part in the nominating process, BUT, why the f*ck isn't this track on the list?:
Luomo - "Synkro"

cause it sucks

no seriously though i think maybe because it came out way back in 2000 people forgot about it

how about for the next poll we let it sneak by w/ any other 2000 tracks, it'll be 1988-2000 and 2000-2012

Probably cause virtually everyone will be voting for tessio instead?

I would have voted for "Synkro" over "Tessio" but I always forget that those singles didn't come out until the same year as the album; such promptness is so unusual in dance music.

I actually nominated Synkro, and nobody noticed. Sad now.

i would vote for synkro over tessio too. i also want to vote for lots of other stuff that isn't on the list (PELE BLOSS??) but i didn't nominate anything so sucks to be me i guess.

I actually nominated Synkro, and nobody noticed. Sad now.

― Josiah Alan, Wednesday, 6 June 2012

I think a few got culled along the way maybe to keep the numbers down

I think something funny happened when I copy and pasted everything into the google doc. As mentioned above some stuff went missing (including, I should note, some of my own noms). That shouldn't stop people from including things, though.

Did you get my ballot, the late great? I didn't get a response and wanted to check it had reached you. The fate of mid-00s electro-house depends on it. ;)

What was decent electro house from mid-decade? Never Be Alone?

There are no entries matching mock n toof

There are no entries matching idjut boys

just do a write-in vote for your favorites

tbh tho if they didn't get nominated they probably wouldn't have placed

i didn't forget about pele bloss but i wouldnt put it in the top 50

yeah DL i did get your ballot

used your real name on the list, apologies

There are no entries matching idjut boys

i think this is because of some discussion in the nom's thread about trying to steer clear of edits for this poll, though there are loads of exceptions that snuck through

i prob would have nom'd some idjuts otherwise

tbf i don't think the idjuts have really been working in "house" mode for awhile now unless you count the (sporadic / rare / obscure) droid EPs

there are probably parts of "puddle & spout" that are at least as house-ish as a kdj or theo track but i wasn't gonna nominate some obscure shit that wasn't going to get any votes

if i had i'd probably nominate "oochie coochie"