Rolling Teenpop 2006 Thread

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed
Not all messages are displayed: show all messages (1918 of them)
Czech cover of "Teenage Superstar" by Ewa, currently on the Czech charts, discussed here and here.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 17 October 2006 15:42 (seventeen years ago) link

Give me enough time and I can usually figure out the chords to a song, but I won't really know what it is I've figured out - that is, I won't be able to make much sense of "this chord in relation to that" even if I can toss around words like "relative minor" and "subdominant." Anyway, I've done a little bit of work on the three recent Aly & A.J. tracks ("Chemicals React," "Greatest Time of Year," and "Not This Year"), the ones the girls wrote with Armato and James. To my surprise, when I start strumming 'em myself I hear all these affinities to the early '60s: Shirelles, early Beatles, etc. So playing along with "But the planets all aligned/When you looked into my eyes/And just like that/The chemicals react" I'm reminded of "It Won't Be Long" and "Baby It's You." And then hearing the way Aly & A.J. hit the notes, I'm hearing eight-to-the-bar strums and power chords that are not played for big metal effect but as a basic groove - which strangely would be a description of the Ramones (power-chord roar through the early Sixties), except that not only do Aly & A.J. sing better and have more complex and visceral arrangements than the Ramones, but also, when I listen to Aly & A.J., I very much don't think "girl groups" or "Beatles" or "Ramones." The girls don't sound like a throwback. I don't know what the difference is, except I want to call Aly & A.J.'s music "darker-hued." This means neither "menacing" nor "somber," just something richer in tone - maybe the way relative minor keys occur, or maybe it's the voices and the instrumentation, something deeper. The sound isn't less up and engaging than the usual stuff you hear on Radio Disney, it's just stronger inside. More full-bodied. I know those adjectives don't explain anything. If all goes well Tim Ellison and Eppy will show up and share their insights.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 17 October 2006 18:58 (seventeen years ago) link

I was in JC Penny this weekend and when I walked into the teenage boys section Girls Aloud "Biology" was playing. It totally threw me for a loop, partially because I had been thinking about that song the morning before. (In how its structure is like Psycho, because I am a nerd.)

Then I went to the men's section and it was Phil Collins or something. Are they actually getting US radio play?

Eppy (Eppy), Tuesday, 17 October 2006 19:36 (seventeen years ago) link

Oops, but we were talking about chord structures. Replaying it in my head "Chemicals React" bleeds into Bon Jovi's "It's My Life" and maybe a Veronicas song. American teenpop is sort of the natural continuation of pop-metal if it hadn't gone industrial, right, and I think how it works is this: 80s pop-metal's big tracks were all metal sonics welded onto 70s rock ballad structures and maybe melodies. This stuff seems to be melding punk onto 60s/70s pop/soul-ballads, Bacharach/David sorta stuff. Lots of passing notes. Except in melding the two they've flattened the rhythmic structure, so chords and root notes change right on the 1 or 3 (beginning or middle of the bar) instead of changing right before or after beats as they did in Bacharach and, I dunno, I guess I've been listening to "Gone Away" way too much lately so that's in my mind. But yeah, I think it takes that sorta variagated chordal structure and chains it to the Ramones chug-chug-chug. I think the verses are almost 70s orchestral pop done with rock instruments and the choruses are 90s power pop, yeah? Sorta kinda? Pop-grunge? I guess I should go listen.

Eppy (Eppy), Tuesday, 17 October 2006 19:45 (seventeen years ago) link

But maybe vocally (I haven't gone and listened yet) Aly & AJ share a certain camraderie with soul ballads? Carole King and Diane Warwick and things?

Eppy (Eppy), Tuesday, 17 October 2006 19:48 (seventeen years ago) link

I still think most of the rock-oriented stuff is a delayed tributary from Cheap Trick with bigger guitar sounds. Really, is there any CT song Ashlee, Lindsay or The Veronicas couldn't cover?

Grey, Ian (IanBrooklyn), Tuesday, 17 October 2006 20:13 (seventeen years ago) link

One thing I've noticed is that Aly/AJ (compared to other Radio Disney stars anyway) build more tension between major/minor, often starting in and resolving to major but making the chord progression seem predominantly minor with vocal melodies (on the verses, I think they tend to hit the major thirds in the chorus, hence "wind at the back"?). "Not This Year": Eb (major) to relative minor C to G minor (with the melody leading into C minor, not emphasizing the major key), but resolves V-I, Bb-Eb. Don't know if this goes to show anything, except that there tends to be a sort of open-ended minor-leaning gloom in the chord progression, where you know it will probably resolve to major anyway even though it feels minor. Smashing Pumpkins might be a referent for the general musical sound, but I guess that counts as "pop-grunge."

nameom (nameom), Tuesday, 17 October 2006 20:53 (seventeen years ago) link

Shine. Just heard this for the first time; it's another Armato-James-Michalka-Michalka track, was added to the rerelease of Into the Rush. I like it a lot, but haven't come close to understanding what's going on. Starts acoustic but also seems as if it's going to be r&b, but then gets very girl-artsy-expressive, kind of, and then brings you to those minor keys or something - the way the voice dips on "every day's another opportunity to shine"; and then about seven-eighths through they make a gigantic change, and suddenly we're in the middle of a movie soundtrack, the camera in the sky panning across the landscape as the sun rises, let's say. And when the voice dips on the final "shine" it's to a more benign tone.

(Can't tell if the "you" in the lyrics is a friend, the listener, or whom. In verse one I thought it might be Jesus, and that still might be right, but "you're the star you're on tonight" seems to be something you'd tell a friend, not a deity. "Like a neighborhood on a city street/I know the path, it knows my feet" is a good couplet - the second half, anyway, the path knowing the feet [not sure how a neighborhood can be on a street, however].)

(Btw, the one track on the original release that Armato and James helped write was "Sticks and Stones.")

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 17 October 2006 22:35 (seventeen years ago) link

Always up for some Aly & AJ talk.

As to Acoustic Hearts of Winter, I have to say I was disappointed. Granted, the two originals are great but couldn't they have:
1) Included more originals
2) Tried to do SOMETHING with the well-known carols they covered
3) At least made some effort to pick lesser known carols that haven't been done a thousand times before?

That said, "Greatest Time of Year" and "Not This Year" are both on the shortlist for top 10 Christmas pop songs of all time. ("All I Want for Christmas Is You" is number one naturally).

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 00:00 (seventeen years ago) link

Oh and by the way no Phil of the Future clips in this "Shine" video, I'm shocked. (By comparison the "Greatest Time of Year" video Frank linked above is almost entirely composed of Phil clips). Surely somebody's not attempting to love Aly & AJ on their own merits, apart from Aly's loveability as an actress are they?

Lots of clips from Cow Belles, which was awful.

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 00:04 (seventeen years ago) link

Let's see, what happened while ilX was in Poxyland?

JoJoToTo: Kelefa Sanneh mentions in his generally favorable review of the new JoJo album that she samples Toto's "Africa."

Platinum Weird does live session on mp3.com. This version of "Crying at the Disco" definitely better than the one on the album. More fuzz-tone, more Yardbirds, more pound pound pound.

Also, as far as I can tell, the Platinum Weird album I reviewed for the New Times NY sub-affiliate didn't actually come out in mid September, as its publicist said it would, but has been postponed until early next year. Don't know this for certain, and am too lazy to find out.

But, in the meantime, Make Believe, the faux 1974 Platinum Weird album, did get released for reals eight days ago, and is available in, like, stores and stuff. Haven't heard it, other than the three tracks that are streamed on their MySpace page, two of which ("Happiness" and "Will You Be Around") are overlaps from the other alb, but in folkier, goopier, deader versions, unfortunately. Another two songs on Make Believe ("Love Can Kill the Blues" and "I Pray") are also on Platinum Weird and from the 30-second Allmusic clips seem to be sung in the same deep, dull round tones, which are supposed to be the fictitious Erin Grace's voice, I guess.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 04:11 (seventeen years ago) link

LINDSAY EXCLUSIVE: 'I need to be looked after.' (OK!)

Hollywood's SECRET NEW DIET PILLS! They Melt Pounds FAST - Who's TAKING THEM & Who's Not. (Ashlee one of four women on this cover, think it was Life & Style)

ASHLEE'S HAD MORE SURGERY! Now She's Got New Eyes and a Softer Chin. Friends Worry: "Her Addiction Is Out Of Control" (In Touch, the full cover for her, not counting the sideboxes)

Is Jess jealous? She wants ASHLEE'S NOSE! (sidebox in Life & Style)

Interesting that in the short interview Jeff linked above, Ashlee calls herself "boring." I hope that she doesn't mean boring, actually, but "normal," i.e., not newsworthy. I believe her in "Autobiography" and "Shadow," where she says she has a million subtleties and that there's so much more to her we haven't seen. But these I presume would be human-being normal subtleties, ways of being, the flavor and character of a particular person, rather than celeb-sized melodrama.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 04:37 (seventeen years ago) link

RE: Shine. It's basically the same formula as The Veronica's "Leave me Alone": soft, looped sample drums/minor key/I-to-VI modulation thingee/'soft' major chorus (emphasis on what looks like an A minor in C (they're playing C chords anyway.) Nice song, though.

Grey, Ian (IanBrooklyn), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 04:41 (seventeen years ago) link

I still keep being amazed at what in comparison are near avant garde structural shapes on Lohan's RAW. At their best--"Black Hole", "I Live for the Day"--they're not so much trad pop songs as teeny operettas.

Grey, Ian (IanBrooklyn), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 04:45 (seventeen years ago) link

"I want to be more famous than the Internet": I never actually saw this "Public Affair" video before (saw the fan-dance version instead). The lead-in is pretty funny, fools around with the celeb thing. "So you guys think there's gonna be even more paparazzi when we get there?" "There'd better be." It helps that I love this song.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 05:03 (seventeen years ago) link

I love the Veronicas "Leave Me Alone," and t.A.T.u.'s very similar (w/ the exact same four songwriters) "All About Us," so that may explain why I take a shine to "Shine." "Shine" does have that strange shift at the end.

Could you say more about "I Live For the Day"? I assume by "structural shapes" you mean chord shifts and harmonic mood changes and the like. The basic song pattern is standard enough: verse, second part of verse, chorus; verse, second part of verse, chorus; break, chorus, finale. Of course, as Lex says, it's MAGNIFICENT (streamed on what seems to be her actual MySpace page), and her "Oh-oh, wanna see you CRAWLin'" at the end is right up there with Jagger's "Black as night, black as coal, I wanna see the sun, blotted out from the sky" in the fadeout of "Paint It, Black" as one of the all-time great song cappers. There are interesting ways that the song throws her from the first part of the verse into the second, or after the first chorus throws her right back into the verse (as opposed to having clear demarcations). And what I call "break" above is actually these extraordinary wails that foreshadow the rocketworks of the finale.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 05:58 (seventeen years ago) link

Frank--I was a bit obtuse last night. What I meant is that the Lohan songs don't *feel* standard--to me anyway--and that structurally, the chorus' seem designed for drama, not easy-access repeating hooks.

The Veronicas are all business--killer intro; catchy verse; maybe a fake-out feedback thing; reapeat-o girl chorus--back to work.

Lohan demands a certain amount of attention paid. "Live for the..." sets a mood, the verse a situation, Lohan's voice fills with her sense of betrayal, and then the chorus comes not so much as catchy, sing-in-shower pay-off, but as an escalation and first indication of how she feels about what was set up in the verse. (And yes--the chorus repeats the signature line, but each sentence complicates it.)

the first time I heard it, my reaction was, What the fuck was that?

Grey, Ian (IanBrooklyn), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 13:39 (seventeen years ago) link

In "I Live for the Day" there's a cool transition from B minor (verse) into E minor/G major (chorus, basically E minor since it never resolves to major, but it's somewhat open-ended like Aly/AJ), with Lindsay jumping up to the unexpected A in the verse to carry it over to the chorus...it's like a sucker punch money note in a variation on the "Since U Been Gone" template. But the song never telegraphs the chorus, so you get this feeling of being hit in the gut when it seems to come out of nowhere. At the end there's one last surprise, great key change to F#minor/A major, which almost imperceptibly ratchets up the intensity (by a half step), still can't quite figure out where they do it, it happens when they go back into the verse for a second before the final set of choruses. So when she sings "CRAAAWlin," she's actually hitting the highest note in the song (C, which would have been the highest note anyway in the old key, but it's a little bit higher).

nameom (nameom), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 14:26 (seventeen years ago) link

Er, intensity up a full step, not half-step.

nameom (nameom), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 14:28 (seventeen years ago) link

And that CRAWLin note is B, not C, which means it actually ties for highest note in the song (but she sings the hell out of it at the end). (Sorry, figured this out on a "piano" supervised by cartoon bears.)

nameom (nameom), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 14:32 (seventeen years ago) link

Also, re Platinum Weird, does that mean that the other non-"classic" album isn't available at all? Someone left this comment a few days ago:

Still searching for Platinum Weird? Best Buy has 'Make Believe' (the '74-style album) packaged along with a disc that is identical to the advance of the '06-style album. Could probably help you locate a copy.

nameom (nameom), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 14:50 (seventeen years ago) link

Idolator calls "La La" a "party-killer." I've seen it kill at parties. I'm sure that's what they meant.

nameom (nameom), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 17:19 (seventeen years ago) link

Yeah, on day one Idolator seemed simultaneously juvenile, conventional, and stodgy, so I never went back. Not fair to cut them off on one try, I suppose, but life is short.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 18:17 (seventeen years ago) link

About Platinum Weird, someone else needs to do the research, as I distract myself too much as it is. A blogster in Scotland said that the '06-style album had been pushed back to next year, but if the thing is part two of a two-fer in places, that's a different story. If you're interested, ask the publicist, Janell Vantrease. vantrease at kensunshineconsultants dot com.

There's a new trend that I don't really understand these days, albums being given limited releases initially and then broader releases later - though I doubt that that's what's happening with Platinum Weird. The Teddybears got a release through indie retailers in late September, but are due to get the release through major retailers in early '07.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 19:05 (seventeen years ago) link

My guitar seems about a half-tone off from Aly's & A.J.'s, so all chord designations are an approximation here, but the verse in "Shine" starts off in A-minor, and the crucial other chord is F (similar to the Stones' "Under My Thumb" and many other songs), which is, um, the subdominant of C, A-minor's relative major. (And now that I've said that, what does it prove?)

The rhythm is pretty much in clave throughout. And the way the vocals are low pitch at the start and given talk-like emphasis (rather than wails and melismas and such) seems very r&b.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 19:33 (seventeen years ago) link

"Like a neighborhood on a city street/I know the path, it knows my feet" is a good couplet - the second half, anyway, the path knowing the feet [not sure how a neighborhood can be on a street, however].

The lyric sites have this as "on a city street," but now I think I'm hearing "on a certain street," which makes a little more sense, since you can interpret the line as "Like [being in] a neighborhood, [like being] on a certain street..."

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 19:37 (seventeen years ago) link

but "you're the star you're on tonight" seems to be something you'd tell a friend, not a deity.

But Jesus isn't just their Savior, he's their Bestest Friend!

nameom (nameom), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 20:03 (seventeen years ago) link

Well, yeah, but does he need their reassurance?

The rhythm is pretty much in clave throughout. That is:

http://img231.imageshack.us/img231/8482/clavesongc4.png

(Bo Diddley does a lot of variants on this, too, even though he's not Cuban.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 18 October 2006 20:12 (seventeen years ago) link

[Great play-by-play for "I Live for the Day" from nameon. Thanks.]

Grey, Ian (IanBrooklyn), Thursday, 19 October 2006 03:03 (seventeen years ago) link

JoJo album streamed over at the AOL Listening Party. (Also Dierks Bentley, Vince Gill, Squarepusher, Aerosmith.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 19 October 2006 20:53 (seventeen years ago) link

New Skye track from the Sims game ("Boyhunter" in Simlish) available at Clouded-Senses fansite.

nameom (nameom), Thursday, 19 October 2006 21:26 (seventeen years ago) link

New Jordan Pruitt song has started streaming on her Myspace in the, what, 3 days since we last talked about her? It's called "Teenager", and it's quite a departure from "Outside Looking In", featuring a bubble-R&B sound rather than a confessional sound, and featuring much more self-assured lyrics (though still on the same theme, how hard it is being a teenager).

I like it, but not as much as "Outside Looking In"

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Thursday, 19 October 2006 23:19 (seventeen years ago) link

K-Sis - Beijos, Blues E Poesia. This is Brazilian, and the one lyric I can understand is "Baby, I love you." She sings that just a bit fantastically, though.

William Bloody Swygart (mrswygart), Thursday, 19 October 2006 23:59 (seventeen years ago) link

Brazilian twin-pop! I'm gonna print up some trading cards, btw.

Babelfish translation:

Composition: (Edson Carvalho [which according to Babelfish means "Oak"])

Crying the ice that you gave to me
Finding that you already it forgot me
I do not know if she was you or if I, girl, girl
Were I you being with a sensation
That I was the track and you, the airplane
You it train and I it station, girl, girl
I remember kisses, blues and poetry.
The salt in the skin, you licked me and I said: "Oh baby, I love you" I remember the face that you made
Will be that I remember what I did not exist?
You he said: "Oh baby, I love you"
Tô in the Bahia and tô feeling cold
Beach tá full; in me all emptiness
I tô for a wire, girl, girl
Broke the rope, I look for to you until not being able more
In the InterNet, bars, in periodicals.
Trombar you is what I want more, girl, girl
I remember kisses, blues and poetry the salt in the skin you licked me and I said: "Oh baby, I love you"
I remember the face that you made, I
I remember day and night, night and day
You said: "Oh baby, I love you... Baby, I love you... Baby, I love you... I love you "

So...this is like conceptually halfway between M2M and tATu? With some Wreckers thrown in?

nameom (nameom), Friday, 20 October 2006 00:51 (seventeen years ago) link

More K-Sis:

"Tem Dias (Que A Noite É Foda)" (more rockabilly, less fetching)

"Experimento". The new wave. Good tune.

The lipsynch.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Friday, 20 October 2006 02:58 (seventeen years ago) link

OK, since everyone's doing musical analysis, here's a tidbit on "Beijos, Blues E Poesia": The verse is basically in A-flat (at least on my guitar), but there's a tendency to use "jazzy" chords, i.e., the ones with numbers in 'em ("D-Flat Ninth" and the like). Didn't really figure 'em out, except I'd say the women are strumming from A-flat to its subdominant chord, D-flat, but with the ninth in place of the third (but no seventh) - i.e., putting do in your chord instead of the usual mi. I think. But the crucial move is when they shift to F-minor (A-flat's relative minor) or some embellishment thereon, the lead singer sings G (do), which is the ninth note in the A-flat chord, and this gives the melody a haunting, unresolved feel. The song is quiet, but stuff like that sung ninth keeps it flowing. Soft songs usually just dull out in the background for me, but this one I like very much.

OK. Question. If I'm writing a review for readers who don't know anything about ninths and subdominant chords and relative minors, is there any way to give them this information without boring them and getting in the way of everything else I want to say? Or even if the reader does know what those technical terms mean, does using them really communicated anything that's essential to what the song does? I made this the Song Of The Day over in the left column of my MySpace profile, and I left out the technicalities and just wrote this: "gentle and pensive, uses complex jazz chords, which don't turn this into 'smooth jazz' but rather keep the flow just unsettled enough so that it is flow, a quiet push in the music. This is the one soft song in a hundred that maintains its emotion throughout." Still might not mean a whole lot to people. I don't know.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Friday, 20 October 2006 22:03 (seventeen years ago) link

G (do), which is the ninth note in the A-flat chord

I meant to write: "G (do), which is the ninth note in the F-minor chord."

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Friday, 20 October 2006 22:07 (seventeen years ago) link

You lost me when you moved on to talking about 'flow'--not sure what that means in the context. "A quiet push in the music" is nice though, evocative.

Grey, Ian (IanBrooklyn), Saturday, 21 October 2006 03:19 (seventeen years ago) link

What you're saying is this isn't just 'fruity jazz chords' as they'd say on Buffy, but that these voicings create a certain mood or tension that propels the song, rather than just embroidering it?

Grey, Ian (IanBrooklyn), Saturday, 21 October 2006 03:24 (seventeen years ago) link

Yeah, that's about it, though I realize I'm being vague. Something about singing a ninth the way they do makes you anticipate a further note. ("Keeps the pages turning" I might say, if this were a suspense novel.) I guess that's standard for songwriting and that there are thousands of songs with ninths where the music doesn't lead you forward nearly as well as "Beijos" does. So I'm saying "Look, K-Sis do this," though then what I describe them doing doesn't seem all that special, and doesn't communicate why this song is special.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Saturday, 21 October 2006 12:06 (seventeen years ago) link

Hey, Frank, I've been meaning to ask what you think of the Timberlake album. I listened to the first half a lot about a month ago and now don't listen to it much at all, although I remember thinking that the anti-crack song and Justin-at-the-piano ballad weren't as bad as most crtics think.

Alfred, Lord Sotosyn (Alfred Soto), Saturday, 21 October 2006 12:54 (seventeen years ago) link

OK, further to the K-Sis stuff, here's a current top-tenner from France - Laurent Voulzy's 'Derniers Baisers'. Now, ver Voulzy is pretty clearly not a teenpop type, so apologies for that, but the song itself is creeping up on my regards somewhat, even though it's basically a feller on a classical guitar singing the melody from 'Sealed With A Kiss' but with new, French words. though they may not actually be new. but, y'know.

Also, I really really really really really need to tell someone how awesome '1980' by Pascal Obispo & Melissa Mars is. It's in the French charts too - again, not exactly teenagers, but she looks about half his age, so, y'know.

Soddit, while I'm at it - Najoua Belyzel's 'Je Ferme Les Yeux' is still bloody amazing. And she's possibly teenaged too. I bet she bloody isn't, but she's got better odds than Pascal Obispo.

So yeah, in summary - French chart-pop: not half bad, sometimes.

William Bloody Swygart (mrswygart), Saturday, 21 October 2006 20:47 (seventeen years ago) link

I talked about Lindsay and Madonna on the country thread last year, mainly 'cause it was a comfortable place to talk, so there really aren't strict limits about whom we should or shouldn't discuss here - and the convo upthread about Lacuna Coil and the Gathering and the like really did give me insight as to what was going on with Kelly and Hilary (in their similarities to and difference from dark metal). My guess is that K-Sis wouldn't strictly speaking be "teenpop" either - but then "teenpop" isn't particularly the pop of America's teens, and up in my intro I wrote: "The teens I know listen to Marilyn Manson and System of a Down, and lots of 'teenpop' is actually for pre-teens, and lots of teenpop is also Adult Contemporary (and I'm waiting for Kelly to break on the country stations), so we can talk about whatever [emphasis added], but here's a good place for an ongoing discussion that includes Jesse and Hilary and Lindsay and Avril and Ashlee and Hampton the Hampster and - yes - Hawthorn and Blink-185 [er, 182], and Weezer (!) and Akon (!) and Gwen (!) and I want Brits to post here so they can confuse us with all their Rachel Stevens and Girls Aloud and Sugababes and who knows who and who knows what."

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Sunday, 22 October 2006 10:53 (seventeen years ago) link

Greg over on his blog prints the lyrics to "Not This Year," and I realize that I'd crucially misheard the words - or not heard, since Aly or A.J.* slurs them - at the start:

"This Christmas card is so contrived
A mannequin looks more alive
Haven't meant a word I've written here
The page is full not one thing sincere"

It's the third line I'd not taken in, which changes the whole meaning for me. It's not a pre-printed card she's calling phony, but her own words.

(*I have no idea which voice is Aly's and which A.J.'s. In fact, looking at them in their videos I don't know who is who either, never having seen their respective TV shows. I suppose I should google their album cover; presumably, Aly'll be on the left and A.J. on the right.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Sunday, 22 October 2006 11:16 (seventeen years ago) link

Meant to link Greg's blog. Here it is:

The Teen Cultural Revolution

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Sunday, 22 October 2006 11:17 (seventeen years ago) link

1) Aly is on the left of the Acoustic Hearts of Winter cover, to the viewer. I assume AJ is the deeper voiced one because that's what the "Rush" video implies. In any event, I like that one better.

2) Do any older-time listeners of Radio Disney know if Hoobastank or Maroon 5 got any plays on RD at the time?

3) I've been watching the WB Summerland lately which has implications on the teen singer/actor discussion thread above as it stars Jesse McCartney and Zac Efron, and also features Sara Paxton as a regular guest star. Zac and Sara were good as alyways, but I have to say I thought Jesse McCartney was surprisingly very good as an actor. Don't care for his singing though. I will probably post my full thoughts on my blog soon.

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Sunday, 22 October 2006 12:58 (seventeen years ago) link

4) Brooke Hogan is currently #1 on the VH1 top 20 videos countdown

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Sunday, 22 October 2006 13:07 (seventeen years ago) link

So it's even more obvious that sounding/being contrived is a major issue for them. I still think the relationship between contrived and deep lines/sentiments in their songs is important, but it doesn't function the way I thought it did in this song...which might mean that I like it even more, though I wasn't having any problems liking it already (this is probably my third favorite song by them..."Rush" is the best and "One of Them" gets the #2 spot because it genuinely scares me).

I saw them do "Chemicals React" on the Megan Mullally show, seemed like their voices were distinct (Aly's voice was stronger and less pinched), but on record it's not clear.

nameom (nameom), Sunday, 22 October 2006 15:15 (seventeen years ago) link

3) Hoobastank currently has three songs eligible, which (I assume) means they've had hits in the past (probably "The Reason"), but I can't find old Top 30 results through the site or Mediabase. Maroon 5 has no songs eligible, but it might have been a Gnarls Barkley sorta thing where they received some airplay but no additional support.

nameom (nameom), Sunday, 22 October 2006 15:23 (seventeen years ago) link

(Take it back Gnarls is eligible, but Maroon 5 might have been back in the day, not sure)

nameom (nameom), Sunday, 22 October 2006 15:37 (seventeen years ago) link


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.