Rolling Teenpop 2006 Thread

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed
Not all messages are displayed: show all messages (1918 of them)
What's the deal with Yo Gabba Gabba, anyway? (The "Ren and Stimpy" to Slumber Party Girls' "[insert product] Show"?) Is it ever actually airing? I read an update from July that said there might be DVDs in the future, but no television distribution. It needs an all-media blitz, but instead it's probably the first children's show hyped exclusively through blog buzz.

nameom (nameom), Monday, 25 September 2006 02:16 (seventeen years ago) link

darn, I missed most of Ashlee on the Charlotte Church show. Will try and catch the repeat later this week. Nose job or no nose job, though (and the schnozz is still quite distinctive IMO) she certainly looks nothing like her sister

I'm tempted to go see her in Chicago now, actually.

zebedee (zebedee), Monday, 25 September 2006 10:37 (seventeen years ago) link

I think Michelle's "Everywhere" would have been better if Slade had been backing her up and singing along. Or the Dolls. Or the Ying Yang Twins. Wouldn't mind these guys taking a shot at "La La," as well.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 25 September 2006 14:05 (seventeen years ago) link

I try to grow up but I am chased by my fears: Aly & A.J. "I Am One of Them" as AmberWatch PSA.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 25 September 2006 18:40 (seventeen years ago) link

This is really disturbing. The kind of "alertness" that they're suggesting (in the song) strikes me as more of a paralyzing fear of strangers and the outside world ("It's hard to look outside my door/ with all the news reports and more"), not really great as a spokesperson message.

But maybe it's appropriate for the AmberWatch foundation, judging from a recent initiative:

Children wearing an AmberWatch® can call attention to themselves at the touch of a button when threatened or scared. The AmberWatch’s trademarked alert signal and bright flashing LED lights call immediate attention to a child threatened with abduction or abuse.

Strange that the missing children site Aly and AJ referred to in their liners promotes the opposite message:

It is much more beneficial to children to help them build the confidence and self-esteem they need to stay as safe as possible in any potentially dangerous situation they encounter rather than teaching them to be "on the look out" for a particular type of person. The "stranger-danger" message is not effective and, based on what we know about those who harm children, danger to children is greater from someone they or their family knows than from a "stranger."

nameom (nameom), Monday, 25 September 2006 20:36 (seventeen years ago) link

Well, yeah, you're right, but I find something profound - not wise and articulate, but deep - in lines like "I try to grow up but I am chased by my fears" and "Don't let nobody tell you your life is over" - especially when put in contrast with "Into your head, into your mind, out of your soul, race through your veins, you can't escape, you can't escape." I.e., what you can't escape is the call of the world and the call of the wild. Race through your veins. "Can you feel it, can you feel it, rushin' through your head, rushin' through your head, can you feel it, can you feel it?" (Raw power is a guaranteed O.D. Raw power is a laughin' at you and me. Can you feel it? Can you feel it?) And the ultimate advice is, "Into the rush, you don't have to know how, know it all before you try." ("Both of us broken, caught in a moment, we lived and we loved, and we hurt and we jumped, yeah.") So: life scary, life not fair, you have to throw yourself into life to find your voice. They haven't yet tried to say it all at once in the same song ("Raw power got a healing hand/Raw power can destroy a man"). Maybe that's to come.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 26 September 2006 15:59 (seventeen years ago) link

There's a smashing clip on Launch Yahoo of Platinum Weird playing "Will You Be Around" live, with Kara herself smashing in mini-skirt and fishnets (go here, and under Videos click "Will You Be Around: Live@Yahoo! Music Exclusive Performance"). There's a charming awkwardness to the way she gets into emotive postures.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 26 September 2006 16:25 (seventeen years ago) link

I guess I'm overreacting.

All your doing, is taking these amazing songs full of compassion and care, letting your stupid little brain think the tiniest most far from reality thing about a part of the lyrics like I-I-I-I-I, and becoming freakishly paranoid about it!!!! What is your problem?!

nameom (nameom), Tuesday, 26 September 2006 23:37 (seventeen years ago) link

Coaching baseball this week I discovered that the most hummed or whistled song among 12 year-old boys is "Does Your Chain Hang Low."
-- curmudgeon (curmudgeo...), September 27th, 2006 6:07 AM.
are you sure it wasn't "do your ears hang low"

-- deej.. (clublonel...), September 27th, 2006.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Whatever it's called, you know it's based on some old old traditional one...
Oh yeah, Kelefa wrote about it in the NY Times--

September 17, 2006 N.Y. Times
Playlist
Yo, Do Your Ears Hang Low?
By KELEFA SANNEH
Jibbs

It is one of the oldest tunes in the American repertory. In the 19th century it was a minstrel mainstay known, depending on the lyrics, as “Zip Coon” or “Turkey in the Straw.” More recently the same tune has been appropriated for a children’s song (“Do Your Ears Hang Low?”) and for the ice-cream-truck jingle that you may be hearing for a few more weeks. And now, thanks to the St. Louis rapper Jibbs, the old song provides the basis for a new hip-hop hit, “Chain Hang Low” (Geffen), which should still be playing on the radio long after the ice cream trucks have gone into hibernation. He raps — brays really — the verses and a chorus of children sings the refrain (“Do your chain hang low? Do it wobble to the flo’?/Do it shine in the light? Is it platinum? Is it gold?”). Perhaps without meaning to, Jibbs has updated one of the most popular melodies of the blackface era, reprising a song that has been stuck in American heads for a few centuries."


-- curmudgeon (curmudgeo...), September 27th, 2006.

curmudgeon (DC Steve), Wednesday, 27 September 2006 15:01 (seventeen years ago) link

A thirteen-year-old I know has "Chain Hang Low" as the song on her MySpace page.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 27 September 2006 16:49 (seventeen years ago) link

Supa Dups' Black Chiney Remix of Rihanna's "Unfaithful" is more enticing than the original. The reggae beat makes it go down much easier. According to Kelefa, the remix is a hit in the Caribbean. (Welcome home, Rihanna.)

(And you can download it free from Supa Dups' MySpace page.)

Rihanna's probably the most played nonteenpopper on Radio Disney (more than Bowling for Soup, Gnarls Barkley, Weezer, Tashbed, Powter, Usher, Black-Eyed Peas, Rascal Flatts, JoJo [whom I'm counting as a nonteenpopper, since her base of support seems to be CHR-Pop]). Of course, RD will never play "Unfaithful," but that doesn't mean the Disney audience won't make its way to that song.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 27 September 2006 17:41 (seventeen years ago) link

The attack of the Bels:

New on Disney this week: Belanova "Eres Tu," which is a wimpy Spanish-language version of "What I've Been Looking For" from High School Musical, which Gabreel & Tisdale did much better. (I like the other songs on the Belanova MySpace page more; smooth disco moods, I'd call 'em.)

New on Disney last week: Belinda "Why Wait." Belinda is a Mexican singer who did the great "Angel" a couple of years ago - it's like Madonna at her aching eightiesish best; the sound's too low on this YouTubed vid (you can go hear/see it on Launch Yahoo in its full glory*); it's well worth viewing for its wonderful morbidity. In fact, I insist you watch it. "Why Wait," unfortunately, isn't one-tenth as good. It's on Radio Disney 'cause it's featured in Cheetah Girls 2.)

Her current Mexican single, "Ni Freud Ni Tu Mamá" ("Knee Freud Knee Your Mother") is way better than "Why Wait," though it's no "Angel." I found this info about it on the Web:

"Ni Freud ni tu mamá" el nuevo tema de la superestrella mexicana Belinda, llega esta semana a la radio latina de EUA. Esta canción escrita por la propia intérprete, será la carta de presentación a su nuevo álbum "Utopía," el primero para EMI Televisa Music.

El tema es de corte pop de actitud honesta y decidida, original de la misma Belinda y producido por Kara DioGuardi, productora de estelares cantantes como Kelly Clarkson y Gwen Stefani.

*Don't know if you can get access to it overseas (just as I don't have access to Launch Yahoo's British vids).

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 27 September 2006 19:21 (seventeen years ago) link

Not sure if this or last week (or some week before that) marked the first time in a very very long time there's been NO Hilary Duff in the RD Top 30. Disney so far has had nothing to do with "Play with Fire," which isn't even eligible for online voting. Inexplicably eligible: The Raconteurs - Steady As She Goes. (Best audio at their site.)

nameom (nameom), Wednesday, 27 September 2006 20:04 (seventeen years ago) link

"Steady As She Goes" isn't light years distant from the Jonas Bros' "Mandy" or "Year 3000." Whereas "Play With Fire" is an unabashed Kylie-style club track. That doesn't take it totally off the Radio Disney map; Disney is the only station in Denver that plays anything remotely close to techno and house and big beat, after all. But "Play With Fire" isn't matching up to much of the Disney chart these days. (Not that I expect "Steady As She Goes" to make it either.)

It's an interesting choice on Duff's part. Supposedly the album's going to be more of the same. Maybe she simply loves disco. It's a good track, but about one track per year hits in that style in the U.S. (This was Cascada's year, I guess.) It's not one of the Billboard Top 25 club tracks. It's getting no Top 40 play (well, seven spins nationwide last week). I wonder how it's doing in Australia. What's her relation to Disney? She's still on Hollywood Records.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 27 September 2006 22:14 (seventeen years ago) link

RBD's lame ballad "Tu Amor" is starting to break on on Top 40 and on R&B stations, though it's too early to tell if it'll go big. Swygart and Haikunym were trying to get us to pay attention to these guys earlier this year.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 27 September 2006 22:41 (seventeen years ago) link

Well, inexplicable because it was introduced for eligibility without being voted on (pick/kick), don't understand why they would do that with that song. "Play with Fire" did pretty well on TRL, forget what the peak was but it was regularly in the Top Ten for a while. It's still in the top ten video streams at MTV.com.

nameom (nameom), Wednesday, 27 September 2006 23:06 (seventeen years ago) link

I'm wondering if Duff and Hollywood Records/Disney chose not to go for Radio Disney, thinking that she has to disassociate herself from teenpop if she wants to develop her career. I have no evidence for this; I'm just speculating.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 28 September 2006 04:10 (seventeen years ago) link

Asian version of "Breaking Free," put together by Disney Channel's Asian branch. Rather anemic; Nikki Gil, Vince Chong, and Alicia Pan. They're nowhere up to Zac Efron, Andrew Seeley, and Vanessa Hudgens. (Guess this puts all my grousing about Hudgens' voice in perspective. She certainly can project more passion and personality than these people. "Come Back to Me" still seems really mediocre.)

"Breaking Free," by the way, is written and produced by Jamie Houston, about whom I know almost nothing. A quick Google search finds that a Jamie Houston produced but did not write "It's Oh So Quiet" on the Ice Princess soundtrack, performed by Lucy woodward (and overdone show tune [Dave, didn't you tell me Bjork had done it first?], and he and Woodward wrote "What's Good For Me" which was on her album. Good, rousing, though not up to the best of her Shanks songs (or "Breaking Free"). There's a Jamie Houston on the credits of a couple of Michael Bolton songs; I don't know if that's the same guy. Probably is. Assuming they're all the same fellow, he's got a track on last year's Carlos Santana album, co-writes something on a James Dean Hicks album (guessing it's country), co-wrote the title track on Jessica Simpson's Sweet Kisses, wrote an O-Town song, co-wrote and Aaron Neville song, co-wrote an Aaron Carter song, a Cheetah Girls song, a Jennifer Paige song, etc. etc. etc. Don't think I've heard any but the Woodwards.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 28 September 2006 05:04 (seventeen years ago) link

Humility Award for 2006 goes to Supa Dups:

THE BIOGRAPHY OF BLACK CHINEY. Black Chiney, the sound, like Jesus, had very humble beginnings. The brainchild of Supa Dups it quietly came into being in September of 1999 as a mixed Reggae/Hip-Hop CD.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 28 September 2006 16:06 (seventeen years ago) link

Also referred to as "Jaime Houston" in the Lucy Woodward liners IIRC but I think it was a typo. Thought I saw the name in Girl Next, checking again it was "When There Was Me and You" from HSM. Here's the Bjork video. I always hear one of these lines as "You blow a fuse/ the Democrats lose."

nameom (nameom), Thursday, 28 September 2006 19:00 (seventeen years ago) link

Paris Hilton's great "Nothing In This World" is flopping on Top 40, and Aly & A.J.'s "Chemicals React" is almost nonexistent there (only 73 spins throughout the entire U.S.). However, besides doing well on Radio Disney [and I'm guessing it's doing something but not a lot on MTV], "Chemicals React" is up to number 18 on the Billboard download chart; this has propelled it to 50 on the Hot 100. ("Rush" had peaked at 59.) Stay tuned.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Friday, 29 September 2006 15:30 (seventeen years ago) link

Thanks for linking the Bjork vid for "It's Oh So Quiet"; I enjoy it, though I'm not sure I'd play her version a lot if I owned it, any more than I play the Woodward. But doing musical comedy she's less of a basic irritant or bore than she is when she's weird in art or rock settings. (Maybe. I haven't given her enough of a chance, I guess.) Her decision to stick out strangely in all directions may fit better in a show-extravanganza context. Here's someone lipsynching to what might be Betty Hutton version, which is better than either Lucy's or Bjork's. Though it's not as good as this little bit o' murder.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Friday, 29 September 2006 16:22 (seventeen years ago) link

Why Harry Dumped Lindsay.

(A minibox on the cover of Star. No T of C, and I didn't have time to page through and find out who Harry is.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Saturday, 30 September 2006 18:50 (seventeen years ago) link

Apparently Miley's sister Brandi (assuming older, not sure though) exists, but her Myspace page isn't streaming any music yet. Cites Paramore as a musical influence.

nameom (nameom), Sunday, 1 October 2006 17:54 (seventeen years ago) link

Italian band called Fisting Janet covers "Tangled Up in Me." Reminds me to finally post Skye on Leno from back when the debut came out, recently Youtubed.

nameom (nameom), Sunday, 1 October 2006 18:22 (seventeen years ago) link

Slideshow to Aly & A.J.'s other fear song, "Sticks and Stones," just so the rest of you will know what Dave and I are talking about. (Assuming that there's anyone else left in the room.)

And this is maybe my second favorite Aly & A.J. song, "Protecting Me". A basically blissful song (though one that has fear as its backdrop - IIRC it comes right after "I Am One of Them" on Into the Rush), yet there's something in the melody that gives the sound a weird twist of melancholy. The chords are all major key, but the melody centers around the sol note rather than the do note, and (in my ignorance of music theory) I suppose this has something to do with the hint of beautiful sadness. Also the grain of their voices. I'm referring to the melody parts like right at the beginning where they sing "You, you're always there for me when I need you most, day and night you're by my side, protecting me."

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 2 October 2006 01:44 (seventeen years ago) link

I botched that "Protecting Me" link, so here's another one.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 2 October 2006 02:11 (seventeen years ago) link

Maybe it's kind of super-muso-geeky to ask, but why are melotrons THE iconic keyboard sound in almost every teenpop record? Kelly, Lillix, Veronicas--it's like the default candied lonliness tone.

Grey, Ian (IanBrooklyn), Monday, 2 October 2006 19:05 (seventeen years ago) link

Maybe it's kind of super-ignorant-muso-critic to ask, but what IS the melotron keyboard sound? I don't think I've knowingly heard a melotron, though I gather that I've unknowingly heard it many many times. Which part of which Kelly, Lillix, Veronicas records use it?

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 3 October 2006 16:35 (seventeen years ago) link

I want to take back everything negative I've ever said about Vanessa Hudgens' singing. So what if it's a chirpy whine, at least she's something of a lively and straightahead singer. In other words, she's not Nikki Flores or Josh Hoge, who together combine on an earthbound, witlessly dull version of "Breaking Free". Flores is eighteen and Hoge's twenty-five, but this is clearly aimed for the adult contemporary market, an attempt to do for the song what HSM couldn't: get it radio play beyond Disney. Starts with a clomp of a piano (not a meletron, I take it), and then the pair do all these real-singer-type things, burrs in the throat and flutters on the tongue to express, you know, passion - characterless as far as any real personality goes, but quite irritating. Sort of the worst of what I'd call dinner-club rock 'n' soul. Flores doesn't have a bad voice, necessarily, just bad ideas of how to use it on this song. I might be willing to listen to her do another, though the bits that I do find OK in her performance here seem lifted from Hudgens'.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 3 October 2006 17:02 (seventeen years ago) link


It's a forerunner to samplers--they'd record strings, vocals, whatever, on these literal tape loops and a keyboard would activate them. It's the "Strawbrery Fields", King Crimson sort of sound.

I was wrong about The Veronicas--melotron projection issues?


Kelly--on the bridge of "Beautiful Disaster", playing the quarter note thing; The entire intro of Lillix's "Tomorrow"; and on three songs by the tuesdays, who I think are kind of seminal to the form.

Aimee Mann used them nicely on the I'm With Stupid CD, but that was no suprise, considering her Beatles worship.

I just think its interesting that artists and producers whose audience's are unlikely to get the era-quote are pulling their old melotrons out for their signature spooky/melancholic effect (more likely, samples of the things, which were notoriously undependable instruments.)

Grey, Ian (IanBrooklyn), Tuesday, 3 October 2006 21:29 (seventeen years ago) link

1. Re: Kogan's comment about Belinda above. It's a pretty good song but it's only getting play because it was in Cheetah Girls 2. Cheetah Girls 2, as a movie, was superior to the first but still not good. Raven's mugging is cringe-worthy. They so dominate RadioDisney now I get happy when things like "Kiss the Girl" come on. I pine for the High School Musical days.

2. "Protecting Me" is a pretty good song, but I personally prefer "No One" and "Collapsed"

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Wednesday, 4 October 2006 01:33 (seventeen years ago) link

Ashlee turns 22 today (even though it was yesterday according to the date on this post)!

nameom (nameom), Wednesday, 4 October 2006 01:52 (seventeen years ago) link

3. I have come to the conclusion that Sabrina Bryan's "BYou" is the best Cheetah Girls affiliated tune. For whatever reason, I can't help but love those cheesy inspirational lyrics.

4. Any opinions on "If We Were a Movie"?

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Wednesday, 4 October 2006 12:34 (seventeen years ago) link

Melissa Lefton found on Myspace.

New band Hello (not teenpop but same spirit, the line "this is the crescendo" happens during an ACTUAL crescendo!

Old band Melissa Lefton and the Lef-Tones

And the ONLY commenter ever on Hello's Myspace blogs is...Jena Kraus. I'm gonna go lie down.

nameom (nameom), Friday, 6 October 2006 15:33 (seventeen years ago) link

The reason of not to get rid of K-fed is obvious. She loves him and knows him better than we do in good and also bad way too. there are some people like me who loves others whom are not so perfect and has lack of their charactor. (because i feel it is very human)

(Gorgeous song by the way, came out on an unheralded remix alb last year and it was a single this year, went to number 1 in Israel and top 10 in the Czech Republic, Indonesia, and South Africa. So I can vote for it in Pazz & Jop if I want to, if there is a Pazz & Jop.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Friday, 6 October 2006 19:42 (seventeen years ago) link

Cheetah Girls aren't that bad; they're just not that good either, so we've got all this mediocre Cheetah kiddie r&b clogging up RD. But actually, the Cheetahs only have one song in Radio Disney's top tier (the top 8 are songs with spins in the 70s, and then you drop abruptly to the low 30s). Here are the top eight in Disney airplay over the last 7 days:

VANESSA HUDGENS Come Back To Me
ASHLEY TISDALE Kiss The Girl
CHEETAH GIRLS Amigas Cheetahs
JONAS BROTHERS Year 3000
JESSE MCCARTNEY Right Where You Want Me
HANNAH MONTANA I've Got Nerve
HANNAH MONTANA If We Were A Movie
HANNAH MONTANA Best Of Both Worlds

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Saturday, 7 October 2006 23:25 (seventeen years ago) link

Agree that Sabrina Bryan's "Byou" is better than the other Cheetah product I've heard (sound is mediocre on all the versions that have been YouTubed so far, sorry). Was on a Nick exercise album this year. Robbie Nevil's one of the co-writers. The record is sorta "You Give Love a Bad Name" given a Max Europop treatment, but not as good as that sounds. The vocals are so-so.

The problem with the Cheetah 2 Belinda song is that it's not "Angel."

"If We Were a Movie" is one of the best Hannah Montana songs, and I like Miley's singing a lot, but no Hannah song has ever taken me over the top. Good melody. Also earns points for using the subjunctive.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Sunday, 8 October 2006 00:10 (seventeen years ago) link

Sorry, screwed up the "BYou" link. Here it is.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Sunday, 8 October 2006 00:15 (seventeen years ago) link

Meanwhile, Aly & AJ have done it again, starting off their Xmas alb with this bright bit of holiday joy (a good song, too), the two girls celebrating the time "When everyone is full of love and cheer" - but then they close the alb with the antithesis, an argument, "Not This Year,"* a track that's as good as "Chemicals," with "Rush"-type brooding leading to a "Rush"-type release - but the lyrics refuse the release, or give you a different release, the release you get from defiance. And what are they defying? Xmas cheer, thank you. "This Christmas card looks so contrived/A mannequin looks more alive." And to drive this mood home: "I can't pull off the cheer, not this year, not this year, not this year." Or as David Sylva says on an Amazon comment thread: "The last song, another original, 'Not This Year' is somber and acknowledges the fact that it is all right not to feel joyous during the holiday season; the complete opposite of the first song." But not just somber. The harmonized joy of defiance.

There's something deep going on with these girls. Artists.

(Aly & AJ wrote both "Greatest Time of Year" and "Not This Time" with Antonina Armato and Tim James, the same duo they wrote "Chemicals React" with. Armato and James are the two who wrote Hoku's great "How Do I Feel (The Burrito Song).")

*Unfortunately, no one's YouTubed this song yet.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Sunday, 8 October 2006 00:56 (seventeen years ago) link

Hm, "it's not snow, it's rain coming down"...let it come down, I'm coming clean (well, presumably they don't want it to come down, but recognize it is anyway...hey, the planets align, the rain comes down, the chemicals react, why is this not what I/we expected?). So Aly and AJ are going insane, too ("wash away my sanity"), and I'm wondering where they go with it. Except I'm way more paranoid about it.

nameom (nameom), Sunday, 8 October 2006 02:27 (seventeen years ago) link

Further thoughts on "Not This Year" -- which after a few listens is probably pretty high on a list of best teenpop Xmas songs, the best being "Why Doesn't Santa Like Me?":

Why are they unhappy during Christmas? This is the part that intrigues me and (on paranoid days) makes me nervous. I agree that this song is great, easily better than half of the debut and "Chemicals React," which I still don't really like...one of the great teenpop Xmas singles. Has the holiday been ruined because it's been secularized, schmaltzified? Is this a hop skip and jump away from the War on Christmas?

Um, no (though I think in "real life" maybe the answer for them and their parents is "yes"), that's not it in the song (they're just unhappy, no reasons are really given why), which is why I'm slowly and hesitantly realizing that one thing that makes me "nervous" is that I kinda relate to Aly and AJ. (I'm usually unhappy around Xmas time, too.) So far it doesn't put me in the position of being closer to what (I think) they believe, though "I Am One of Them" come closest to making a political argument that I reject, even if it means misrepresenting my own personal connection to the song (I mean, I watch the same TV they do, see the same "news reports and more," sympathize with their fears). If they were to come out with a song whose message was "I'm alone, I'm afraid, but at least I'm not a monkey," I'd probably reject that, too, even if I identified with the first two parts. But in their songs, they seem to be the first ones to admit they don't really know what they believe.

nameom (nameom), Monday, 9 October 2006 18:13 (seventeen years ago) link

Writing about Emma Roberts has brought back to mind something I've been stewing over for a while. Take the teen stars who are actors/singers.

Aly Michalka as an actress is so warm and light and funny, but as a singer is the exact opposite: deadly serious, and as far as I can tell not much personality in the vocal or live performances. (She's still a good singer, mind you, as far as I can tell, just a kind of robotic one). Emma Roberts is the same way. Her acting is filled with expressiveness and personality, and yet her singing is lifeless and completely devoid of personality, which is part of the reason I don't care for her album at all. Ashley Tisdale the same way? I dunno, she steals the show in HSM (and also in Zack and Cody), her singing though not great does seem to express some personality.

On the other end, you've got Brie Larson and Miley C, who are great, expressive singers but horrible and wooden as actresses.

Is there something so inherently different about singing and acting that nobody can be lively and fun at both? Closest I can think of is Hilary, tho her singing is fairly wooden itself. Am I missing somebody?

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Monday, 9 October 2006 22:01 (seventeen years ago) link

Off the top of my head, Betty Hutton, Gene Kelly, Judy Garland, Barbra Streisand, Dean Martin, Frank Sinatra, Lindsay Lohan, though I suppose Lindsay's the only one pertinent to this thread. I'm not a fan of Streisand's singing style, but it certainly delivers personality. Sinatra has a powerful screen presence, though a limited repertoire. I'm not sure if there's someone who's been absolutely astonishingly great in both acting and singing. (Astaire a great singer, an OK actor; Rogers a great actor, an OK singer.) Maybe there's someone obvious I'm missing. As for Lindsay, she was first rate in Herbie Fully Loaded; her singing hasn't nearly the emotional range of her acting, but it's sure lively. I've no TV, so Hilary's the only other one I've seen act, other than a three-minute clip of Hannah Montana (thought Miley was fine in it, but the clip wasn't really long enough for me to tell). Ricky Nelson was pale in Rio Bravo (Dean Martin was superb); maybe someday I'll run across The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet.

I'd actually think that acting and singing might draw on similar skills, to some extent, so I'm surprised that I can't think of more. I'd call Aly a lively singer, even if "fun" isn't really her thing.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 10 October 2006 03:41 (seventeen years ago) link

How about this guy?

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 10 October 2006 03:48 (seventeen years ago) link

Item in the Times Sunday Styles section about Alex and Brit Smith, who I swear have been mentioned somewhere before. Anyway:

"Five-and-a-half years later, the twins, 20, have just finished recording a pop album with the producers Dallas Austin and Tricky Stewart. Although they left modeling to focus on songwriting, they still devour fashion."

Blah blah fashion. But, you know, Dallas Austin! Tricky Stewart does not ring a bell.

Eppy (Eppy), Tuesday, 10 October 2006 04:16 (seventeen years ago) link

I mentioned them once on Stylus but didn't go further than a name-drop.

How's Paris Hilton as an actress? Does her show count? I might also nominate Meryl Streep as hypothetically pertinent to the thread, Pauline Kael once classified her as an android, which I took to mean she'd be a good teenpop singer (not astounding, but maybe a bit like fellow lovable android Hilary).

Courtney Love? Madonna (ummm)? The cast of Nashville?

nameom (nameom), Tuesday, 10 October 2006 05:11 (seventeen years ago) link

For Frank's Ashlee-in-the-tabloids collection

zebedee (zebedee), Tuesday, 10 October 2006 09:41 (seventeen years ago) link

Lohan is a good one. Certainly a lively actress and I see where you're coming from re: the singing.

Pertinent to this thread there's also Jessica Simpson, who doesn't seem to have too terribly much personality either way as far as I'm concerned. Same with Hayden Panettiere.

Jennifer Lopez comes close to having both, though I don't particularly like her as a singer or actress.

Paris is surprisingly "not bad" as an actress, though certainly nothing to write home about.

Reese Witherspoon, maybe, but we'd have to see more of her singing than just Walk the Line. Certainly a lively actress.

Note how all of the good examples Frank is coming up with are people from long ago (Astaire is a really good one. Not a great actor but certainly a fun and lively one.) What happened to the singer/actor in the last 20 years?

Greg Fanoe (JustFanoe), Tuesday, 10 October 2006 11:16 (seventeen years ago) link

i saw house of wax last night, i cannot get paris teh actor out of paris the icon, and so she might have something there (i could never get liza out of liza or judy out of judy, and so is she could find a way to use her iconicness on screen, it might be interesting) (deos he porn movie count)

anthony easton (anthony), Tuesday, 10 October 2006 12:03 (seventeen years ago) link


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.