Rolling Teenpop 2006 Thread

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed
Not all messages are displayed: show all messages (1918 of them)
I find Vanessa Hudgens' voice slightly annoying: little girly and whining (when I'm not loving Diana Ross, that's what annoys me about her voice too), but not in a big whining way, just sorta, um, little. Think the voice could work well if someone gave her a good freestyle song. "Come Back to Me" is a mediocre r & b track, even if it has gotten 20,305 plays so far today. My guess is that Ashley T. has more long-run music star potential (though I do think Hudgens' & Anonymous Hired Hand's "Breaking Free" was probably the best song in HSM).

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Sunday, 27 August 2006 22:15 (seventeen years ago) link

According to Billboard, the Marit Larsen album drops here on Sept. 11, though neither her Webpage nor her MySpace page mentions this. (If for some lunatic reason you haven't heard her yet, she's streaming her best song, "Only a Fool," on her MySpace page.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Sunday, 27 August 2006 22:27 (seventeen years ago) link

(Marit's total plays are only 50% higher than Hudgens' one day plays.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Sunday, 27 August 2006 22:30 (seventeen years ago) link

Cosmo Girl story on Ashlee was a nonstory, basically. CG writer asks Ashlee about nosejob, Ashlee says, "Can I call you back?"

(I will never be chosen to interview Ashlee, I guess. I'd have asked about the nosejob too. You have to. She's the one who, in Marie Claire, was profiled as working with kids on a project to demonstrate "That beauty comes in all shapes and sizes" and discussing eating disorders. And there she was on the cover with her innocuous, anonymous new nose. The dissonance screams at you. And she's the one who in "Shadow" said that the precondition for her finally being able to love her sister and parents was her realizing that it was "safe outside to come alive in [her own] identity." Not that she might not have good reasons for the nosejob, but she ought to say what they are. She's made the issue relevant. Not to mention that it's relevant to a celebrity anyway. Also, she'd probably have smart and interesting ideas on the subject. In Marie Claire she'd talked of various beauty trade-offs: as a teen, Jessica would use pliers to get into her jeans, while Ashless always wore stretch pants. If Ashlee wants to play volleyball, she can just put on a bra and go, whereas Jessica needs a fortified bra.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Sunday, 27 August 2006 23:00 (seventeen years ago) link

stretch waists, that is.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 28 August 2006 03:38 (seventeen years ago) link

nameon, obviously it isn't inconcievable that Paris Hilton reads Pynchon. I'm not about to make assumptions about her private life. I was only trying to say [obviously inarticulately] that she was reading Pynchon as an intentional subversion of people's expectation. The script acknowledges that Hilton reading Pynchon is jarring (or unexpected). Her private life really doesn't invade this fantasy world in which Hilton would never read Pynchon... and yet look - she is!

Actually, now I'm wondering about a different question. What exactly makes Paris Hilton teenpop music? Because I think the question of who is listening to the album cuts to the essence of how the album is currently occuring. I know neither my sister, nor any of the other teenage girls who give me playlists, are listening to Paris Hilton. And Paris-haters, in my experience, are generally ignoring the album. After a sex video, an album is pretty inconsequencial, I'd guess.

Maybe we're just talking about the album here because it's a convenient place to discuss it, but I feel like it has less and less relevence to teenpop music every time I spin it. The teenpop I've been listening to has been emotionally ecstatic (which Hilton is decidedly not), clean-cut or a subversion of being clean-cut (while Hilton is unapologetically sexualized), and mostly lacking in irony with some exceptions (while Hilton sounds very ironic to my ears - not listening to Hilton, but the singing itself).

Mordechai Shinefield (Mordy), Monday, 28 August 2006 04:39 (seventeen years ago) link

I wouldn't call it teenpop, actually, though it's got some overlap. But I think it's fine to talk about here. And Paris certainly impinges on the teen and kiddie worlds.

Not all teenpop is trying for ecstasy ("Because of You"* and "Shadow" and "Confessions of a Broken Heart," for instance), and of the stuff that does, the ecstasy is often pretty tepid, and the listeners seem fine with that. But I do know what you mean by Paris's sound not fitting. I'm not hearing any "irony," though. In what way is she drawing a deliberate contrast between an apparent and an actual meaning? Is "irony" the word you're looking for here? She may have plenty of meanings in addition to the most obvious ones, but nearly all music does that. (But I'm not yet paying that much attention to the words, so I could just be missing this.)

*Kelly is everything pop rather than teenpop per se, but she's super huge in the teenpop world, and "Because of You"

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 28 August 2006 13:57 (seventeen years ago) link

...and "Because of You" gets as many spins on Radio Disney as "Since U Been Gone."

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 28 August 2006 13:58 (seventeen years ago) link

Edward O, if you ever return here: You said that the Paris "melodies are generally not particularly engaging." Do you still think so? I can see how you might think that the performances are not engaging, or the vocals sound disengaged, or something (they don't sound disengaged to me, by the way, just fairly low-pitch and achieving their presence by being layered on in overdubs). But, for instance, "Jealousy" and "Nothing In This World" have very pretty tunes, to my ears.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 28 August 2006 14:05 (seventeen years ago) link

Without my noticing (it peaked in Mar, Apr, May, when I wasn't doing much RD listening), B5's "Keep Your Head in the Game" has been the fourth most played song on Radio Disney this year. (1 through 3: "1985," "Rush," "We're All In This Together.") It's got an HSM tie-in, but B5 were strong players on Radio Disney already. An old-fashioned r&b boyband (goin back to New Edition and Boyz 2 Men, etc.), w/ some rap thrown in. Nothing terrible, nothing great.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 28 August 2006 14:26 (seventeen years ago) link

Paris has got the highest ratio of good tunes I've heard on any album this year. I am also impressed by how Paris has deemed unnecessary to include any ballads on this album.

Baaderonixx: the lost ILX years (baaderonixx), Monday, 28 August 2006 14:35 (seventeen years ago) link

(Actually, what was interesting in the Cosmo Girl story was that most of the piece was the writer's insistence that Ashlee had good reason to blow her off, her argument being that girls have a right to do their beauty any way they want and any way they can, and it's rude to come in and question them about it. Like, it's a personal decision. If someone you knew in school went away for a week and came back with a new nose, wouldn't it be rude to question her about it? [Um, not really.] The reasoning seemed incoherent. How is a celeb's public image her private life?)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 28 August 2006 14:35 (seventeen years ago) link

According to Billboard, the Marit Larsen album drops here on Sept. 11, though neither her Webpage nor her MySpace page mentions this.

http://www.cduniverse.com/productinfo.asp?pid=5534976&style=music&cart=385173247&BAB=E

(That is the wrong CD cover image, right?)

Rockist_Scientist (RSLaRue), Monday, 28 August 2006 14:45 (seventeen years ago) link

Ha! That cover is Gila, who I've never heard but who were a '70s Eurorock/krautrock group associated with Amon Duul II and the like (according to Allmusic). Does CDuniverse just post Gila album covers when they don't have access to the real ones?

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 28 August 2006 14:52 (seventeen years ago) link

Here's the "Tap That" link again. Don't want it to get overlooked amid all the Parisian matter. Evanescence goth girl jumps to Max-n-Luke and goes Salt 'n' Pepa hip-hop in the same song! Also, her latest blog post says "BREAKUPS SUCK BALLS! For the OTHER asshole, that is." So maybe, like, she could use some reassurance.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 28 August 2006 14:52 (seventeen years ago) link

And then Megan let's Kelis speak for her.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 28 August 2006 15:01 (seventeen years ago) link

"Fragile" seems to be the best of McCauley's pre-"Tap That" tracks. She's got a real wall-blaster of a voice, and she can put a high pitch in it whenever she wants to slice you. The melody goes to otherworld eeriness but the voice stays super strong. No wispiness for her. "I am fragile but I am strong enough," she says, as she invites us to follow her to hell. "To be free I'll need my hands tied." ???? (Yeah, I know she's newly single and all, but I kinda don't think I've got what it takes.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 28 August 2006 15:51 (seventeen years ago) link

I was a bit hesitant to love Megan at first cos in Tap That she hints at that annoying self-righteous aggression I dislike in P!nk, but after a few listens I was definitely on board. It doesn't sound that different from the other Max Martin songs, but the sort of rap-style talky bits make it so much fun and the chorus is extremely catchy. The song has real energy and shows everything that wimpy bores like Hilary and Lindsay are doing wrong, in terms of poptasticness anyway - time will tell if this approach gets her any further. Megan is having heaps of fun and sounds like a real 18 year old, not trying to be too mature but neither is she bothering to please parents of younger kids. Hopefully this will appeal to people her own age but she's certainly not playing it safe and she could just go the same way as the other fun pop-rockers like Fefe and Lillix.

Actually, speaking of Lillix I am very confused about their album release so perhaps one of you Americans can clear this up. On Amazon it says Inside The Hollow was released in July but there's not even a tracklisting and it says it'll take 3 to 6 weeks to arrive, suggesting it is not actually released at all. Was the album originally meant for that date but put back? If so it seems strange that Amazon hasn't acknowledged this. I really want to hear the album but the cheapest I can find it to order to the UK is £16.99 and no sign of it yet on CD Wow.

Jessica P (Jessica P), Monday, 28 August 2006 17:53 (seventeen years ago) link

My promo copy says it's due out on 6/16/06. Really like the one Megan McCauly track I heard, but only listened once (and I think it faded out early on Myspace).

Jessica, how does Hilary do it wrong? She's anonymous, but I don't think she's "wimpy," really, just...unobtrusive? Still distinct, but she gives herself over to just about any style you can throw at her. I agree that, er, poptastic-wise (as I think you're defining it), Lindsay is uneven (first less so than second album, but the more I listen to the second album, the more I like it. At least as recently as a few months ago, haven't listened since then except to "I Live for the Day").

nameom (nameom), Monday, 28 August 2006 18:46 (seventeen years ago) link

Frank, I definitely mean irony. There is musical irony, in that the songs involve these great romances, and yet her voice is careless, breezy (at best), droning (at worst). The words and production imply a large amount of emotion, but Paris Hilton expends none in her contribution to the album. So she's undercutting the expectation of what a love song sounds like (it sounds like she just doesn't care).

Then there is lyrical irony as well. Like in "Stars are Blind" where she's simultaneously discussing and subverting a sort of pure love. "But you can see the real me inside" aafter "Some people never get beyond their stupid pride," implies this revelation of the true Paris. You're going to see Paris, beyond your prideful condemnations of her. But she immediately follows with "And I'm satisfied, oh no, ohh." So she's just gotten through telling us that we'll see beyond this oversexed image that we're used to, and follows immediately by changing the meaning of "see the real me inside," into a sexual phrase.

Plus, the title of the song: On one hand "Stars Are Blind" in context refers to the fates. The fates are blind, love is blind, Paris Hilton can fall in love with anyone because she's such a deep person. "Got a haert and soul and body," etc. But it also means that stars, like Paris Hilton, are literally blind. The subtext of the song is that she's literally seducing this good boy. "I'm perfect for you," reminds me of the scene in Evita where Evita keeps reassuring Peron that "I'll be good for you." So I hear this other story going on where the sexualized Hilton keeps undermining the potential good girl who wants a good guy. That she's literally blind to this condition makes it the complete opposite of the original meaning of "Stars are Blind." It isn't love that's blind, it's Paris Hilton that's blind.

Mordechai Shinefield (Mordy), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 00:22 (seventeen years ago) link

According to Billboard, the Marit Larsen album drops here on Sept. 11, though neither her Webpage nor her MySpace page mentions this. (If for some lunatic reason you haven't heard her yet, she's streaming her best song, "Only a Fool," on her MySpace page.)

I heard this a month ago and was really, really pleasantly surprised by it. Why didn't I venture into this thread before? I tend to avoid Rolling threads in general it seems. Don't know why. The size overwhelms me methinks.

Cunga (Cunga), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 01:32 (seventeen years ago) link

Cunga, the rolling threads are the subcults of ilX (like the great Jay-Z/Nas throwdown thread of old, which invented its own culture).

Mordy, that's a great post. I guess I need to pay more attention to the words, rather than just sitting back and hope they come to me some day.

Thing is (as I've been saying), I actually love the sound Paris and crew got out of her voice. It's like husky butter, whereas I bet unaccompanied and single-tracked it's just a husk.

And maybe I'm coming to think that that voice is a personality, after all.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 03:44 (seventeen years ago) link

The Lillix album comes out in Canada, like, right now (August 29). As for the U.S., their publicist told me a month ago that the album had been pushed back to January, and now the Lillix MySpace blog says this:

Hola

We've been getting many messages asking about our US release date recently, so I thought I'd take this chance to give you all an update. So far NO US RELEASE DATE has been scheduled, but we can tell you it will be sometime early next year. Fingers crossed, if all goes well! Our label Maverick is no longer in existance, and we are now only on Warner. This has caused a bit of a setback as far as the US goes, but don't worry, we still plan on releasing Inside the Hollow and touring "south of the border" :)

For all of our glorious wonderful fanships living outside Canada or Japan, you can order Inside the Hollow online from www.lillix.net or www.maplemusic.com.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 04:09 (seventeen years ago) link

BEAT UP PARIS HILTON AND GET A RINGTONE.

(Ad on MySpace.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 04:20 (seventeen years ago) link

Well, I listened to some of the Paris and first off, and not that it's of note or a defining thing, but wither she can't sing or her producers didn't let her. Most of the vocals are doubled or quadrupled, pitch corrected and rife with likely punch-ins.

Which in a way, is the perfect Paris vocal--100% processed and in every way an assemblage of parts recpnfigured by code.

If the context were more what passes for post modern, if there were a knowing smile somewhere, or, well, anything, it could be sickly brilliant.

But as is, it's the perfect audio for Maxim readers--the only imaginable audience. And even they might be put off by the plastic.

This sounds like I don't like Hilton--it's not that. I do find 'her' faintly scary, like some strange devolution, or the result of some mad labs' persona stripping experiments.

Grey, Ian (IanBrooklyn), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 06:11 (seventeen years ago) link

Is Megan doing the raps on "Tap That"? The first time I heard it, I thought it was Salt-N-Pepa.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 06:17 (seventeen years ago) link

The fact that something is pitch-corrected is something entirely unnoticeable by me. That vocals are quadrupled is noticeable, because I hear it as more than one voice. But again, the way I feel the voice has nothing to do with plastic. "Plastic" is glossy, whereas Paris's voice doesn't have a sheen at all. It's husky. It's got fuzz and burrs and breath in it. (And I rarely look at Blender, much less Maxim.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 06:25 (seventeen years ago) link

Jessica Simpson's "You Spin My Round (Like a Record)." I like "A Public Affair" a lot. This I like much less, and most of what I do like about it is because of the melody and the beats. The voice is deliberately subdued, brought down to breathiness, which isn't bad in itself - it's what Jessica did on "These Boots Are Made For Walkin'," too, and of course deep breathiness is a feature of Paris's singing, which I've been lauding. Even subdued, Jessica's voice is clearer and louder than Paris's. But on this track it's just kind of... there. I don't know.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 06:46 (seventeen years ago) link

Ian, can you really tell the extent to which it was pitch-corrected or somehow make a relevant guess about the number of punch-ins that were done?

Tim Ellison (Tim Ellison), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 06:54 (seventeen years ago) link

Tim--when you double and quadruple vocals, you inevitably get a sort of wavering tone--like Amy Lee on the beginning of "Call Me When You're Sober", except that starts out as a single vox, then a double as an intended effect.

Obviously, Lee has a swell voice--so if even she gets that frequency-beating effect--like most folks--no, all folks--do, then Hilton's must be corrected for that silky rayon sound.

And the punch-ins--well, the songs' melodies are very punch-in-friendly, and while I'm guessing, I can't imagine Hilton would be able to do entire takes--and really, why bother trying. That's not a dis on her; it's just a way of making stuff.

Grey, Ian (IanBrooklyn), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 07:08 (seventeen years ago) link

Of course, you can actually *hear* the auto-tune on Lohan's voice sometimes, but it hardly matters. What she lacks in singing experience--she *has* a voice--she more than makes up for in framatic chops, which she to spare.

Grey, Ian (IanBrooklyn), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 07:13 (seventeen years ago) link

er--"dramatic" chops. I don't know how good her framaticism is.

Grey, Ian (IanBrooklyn), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 07:14 (seventeen years ago) link

Ian I totally thought you meant to use "framatic chops". I decided it meant something like "knows how to frame a lyric with the perfect vocal performance of it".

Tim Finney (Tim Finney), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 07:30 (seventeen years ago) link

What I maybe like best about the Megan McCauly track at the moment is that it's like the potential of "U and Ur Hand" realized (different subject matter, she's going after the guy this time, but the chorus doesn't depend on a lame joke and it's still funny and there's still basically a punchline of sorts referenced in the title). And it's the perfect union of not only what Pink is trying to do, but what Marion Raven and a few others are doing, which is the absorption of Evanescence in the Luke/Max formula. Kind of amazing that it juggles all of these things effectively, in a way it might be the Luke/Max track of the year that isn't "4ever" (if Paris doesn't count, since it's just Luke).

According to Perez Hilton and Jessica P and Myspace, fan_3 is in a new band. They didn't write the track of the year. Shut Up Stella...listening to "Country Lemonade" now, kind of a nice silly c. 2000 teenpop throwback like Daphne and Celeste with...I dunno, B*Witched maybe in the chorus + some funny fan_3 verses ("I'm gonna get so Big and Rich -- shit -- and get high with the Dixie Chicks") OK, maybe this is the best thing ever.

"What sets the group apart from the status quo is their wide range of musical influences. The combination of Fan_3s hip hop background, Kristens SoCal punk rock and Jessies singer-songwriter world gives their music a refreshingly unique and surprisingly catchy edge, as if someone laced an Eve and Green Day sandwich with a healthy dose of Spice."

A very healthy dose of Spice, if by Spice they mean the first wave of post-Spice teenpop.

nameom (nameom), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 14:19 (seventeen years ago) link

Anyone know how I can get in contact with Storch for interview? Apparently he is "in between" handlers right now. I've got space in a paper promised if I can get the interview. :-P

Mordechai Shinefield (Mordy), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 14:29 (seventeen years ago) link

Shut Up Stella are great! They are my new discovery of the moment, although not quite beating Tap That for aceness so far.

I'm not sure exactly what my problem is with Hilary because she seems in theory to be a great pop star but there's just this sense of trying too hard which I find kind of embarrassing. Like many US pop acts, she has good intentions with her pop-rock and electro-pop singles, but somewhere along the line something is going wrong because she's doing the kind of music I love and I am just not interested at all. I've nothing against Hilary herself, although she could do with being a bit more 'rough around the edges', but I just don't connect to her music at all. Some of her songs I don't mind listening to eg. Come Clean and Beat of My Heart, but I've never made any particular effort to listen to them. It could just be my personal taste doesn't match with her musical output, but it seems strange when I usually love electro-pop and rock-pop and I wouldn't consider myself particularly fussy. I just think for such a big star she really is not making as good music as she has the power to do. Her greatest hits was a US no.1 so it can't be difficult to get good producers on board, but for some reason she's never made a song that I've downloaded and played more than once immediately. I don't know if it's just me or if I'm right and she really isn't as good as she should be.

Jessica P (Jessica P), Tuesday, 29 August 2006 19:54 (seventeen years ago) link

hello, thread!

Sterling Clover (s_clover), Wednesday, 30 August 2006 15:58 (seventeen years ago) link

Hello, Sterling. Nice to see you again.

Thread (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 30 August 2006 16:22 (seventeen years ago) link

Vanessa Anne Hudgens' "Come Back To Me" still seems weak, though I'm growing to tolerate her voice more. I'm surprised at how '80s r&b it sounds - I could imagine Paula Abdul doing this (except she'd reject it for being boring). Paula pushed her voice more, which might have been irritating but which helped to make her chirpy whine distinctive. "Come Back to Me" is getting a relatively poor 18 plays (still behind "We're All In This Together" and "Breaking Free," which have been around for months, and I've finally promoted "Breaking Free" to the category Good Song, even if it is HSM).

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 5 September 2006 18:18 (seventeen years ago) link

Relatively poor 18 plays on Radio Disney, that is. It's getting fewer in my house.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 5 September 2006 18:51 (seventeen years ago) link

Latest news from Brie Larson:

PHONECALLS ARE GREAT
here are some highlights from the one I just had with Sir Mimster.

G: I hate you.
B: I can't stand you.
G: No, I can't stand YOU.
B: Well, I'm sitting down.

or also.

B: Dude, there was 18,000 people there.
G: Shit.
B: I KNOW. I did a show once for 6,000 people and it was too much for me to handle.
G: Thats like, more than double.
B: Well, its closer to "less than triple"
G: Yeah.
B: Yeah.
G: Hey, ISN'T it triple?
B: No.
G: 6,000 times 3 is....
B: 18,000.
G: Right.
B: Oh uuuuhhhhh. Shut up.

In other news. I like:
1.) the sound of pennies falling.
2.) my armpit smells like dogfood.
3.) "pool's gone."
4.) friend request from The Morning Benders.
5.) the beast.
6.) diva eating dunkaroos.
7.) distance has no way of making love, understandable.
8.) blue.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 5 September 2006 22:01 (seventeen years ago) link

ANOTHER NEW LOOK FOR ASHLEE
First the nose, now...

[I didn't get a chance to read the piece, however. The headline was in a sidebox on the cover of I forget which tab, so one can predict that the article is approximately a paragraph and doesn't tell us a whole lot about Ashlee. Oh, and Us Weekly believes that Jessica has a new boyfriend.]

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 6 September 2006 11:26 (seventeen years ago) link

and Us Weekly believes that Jessica has a new boyfriend.] -- Frank Kogan (edcasua...), September 6th, 2006.

Singer John Mayer, who's currently on tour with Sheryl Crow. There's some tab headline about how "a friend says he makes her heart flutter" or something like that.

curmudgeon (DC Steve), Wednesday, 6 September 2006 11:45 (seventeen years ago) link

But does he make her endorphins dance?

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 6 September 2006 18:10 (seventeen years ago) link

Maybe Aliana Lohan (Lindsay's little sister) will follow the Hilary Duff route? Starting with her Xmas album (but no singles preceding it)...

http://www.tommy2.net/2006newsgraphics/alilohanearly.jpg

nameom (nameom), Wednesday, 6 September 2006 22:24 (seventeen years ago) link

I've got one of those Voice mini-reviews due for Platinum Weird in, um, like, well, 6 hours ago and I still haven't figured out why the album isn't better. I'd certainly recommend you listen to it, especially to "Avalanche" and "Somebody to Love" (both have got a good Rolling Stones groove motion, among other things) and "Will You Be Around" and "Crying at the Disco" and "All My Sorrow" - the last of which is too lethargic but has a moment in the refrain where Kara sings "Your sorrow, too," and the piano does a little descent that's as sweetly, sadly gorgeous as the piano in "Fly." On four of the album's tracks John Shanks joined Stewart and DioGuardi in the songwriting, and those are four of the five I just mentioned (all except "Will You Be Around"). (Btw, the album version of "Will You Be Around" is far better than the one on Platinum Weird's MySpace page, where they pretend it was sung by the fictitious Erin Grace so Kara makes her voice go round and burnished.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 7 September 2006 04:29 (seventeen years ago) link

(Nothing about the promo campaign for Platinum Weird makes any sense to me. It's built around a barely amusing 25-minute mockumentary about how the young drug-addled Dave Stewart was captivated by the mysterious and flighty Erin Grace, with whom he formed a band in the early '70s that enthralled record company execs and luminaries such as Mick Jagger and Elton John and George Harrison. Platinum Weird were all set to record their album when Erin disappeared, leaving a demo tape as the band's legacy. What strikes me as odd about this mockumentary, beyond the fact that I can't figure out why anyone thought this witless story would help sell a record album in the '00s, is that Dave Stewart's actual taste in musical partners isn't for flighty and mysterious femmes but for deep-voiced toughies like Annie, Barbara, and Kara (and Mick, for that matter). And maybe the sad underlying truth is that for this record's target audience (Mainstream Top 40? Adult Contemporary?), the fact that Kara helped create a substantial amount of the best pop music of the last six years is considered less likely to sell the record than is a connection to the vapid fictional nonentity Erin Grace. And that'd be because most of the performers (e.g., Ashlee, Lindsay, Hilary, Paris) she made her music with have zero cred, Kelly being the major exception. Or maybe there was just going to be no promo budget anyway, so Dave took the opportunity to finance his own thing, which he thought would be a hilarious way to poke fun at his past. I wonder what Kara thinks of all this. Maybe she's most comfortable playing second fiddle. She wants to come second, even to a nonentity.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 7 September 2006 10:53 (seventeen years ago) link

Anyway, to the album itself. It's in the Fleetwood Mac/Sheryl Crow pop-rock line, which was good in its day but has fallen into dullness in the '00s, Shanks assisting in the dullness (he helped with Sheryl's and Stevie's recent albs). Kara's got a strong voice and she's going to use it, so at the end of some of these tracks she'll go to gospel-based fireworks, shouting and vamping over the background vocals. This is kind of so-what, maybe 'cause what she's saying is kind of so-what. What I said upthread about the lyrics to "Avalanche" not jelling is even more true of the rest of the songs. "When the rain comes tumblin', tumblin' down, will you be around, will you be around/When the pain starts comin', comin' out, will you be around, will you be around?" is well-crafted(those "tumblin's and comin's" are well-designed to be sung) but the idea is hackneyed even for weather imagery. (Compare to the rather startling "Let the rain fall down and wake my dreams/Let it wash away my sanity" in Hilary's "Come Clean.") "The tears on my face come down like rain." "Don't want to be alone on this planet they call Earth" - like, as opposed to being on some other planet? "Have you thrown a wish into the ocean/And watched it slowly float away." (In my notes, right after I wrote that one down, I said, "You know, I'm not looking for bad lines. I'm just writing things down as they hit me.") "Let's go back to living, instead of always throwing love away." "Only love can kill the blues." On the album's first track she sings "There's never pleasure without any pain," which you could say is the theme of the second Ashlee album - to see the light you need the dark, etc. - but Ashlee's found a way to build stories around this, giving her albums ten times the emotional complication and intellectual restlessness of anyone else's. While on the Platinum Weird album you have imagery with no story to connect to, so it ends up as floating platitudes. I'd pretty much guessed that Ashlee herself brought the complication and restlessness and that Kara and John helped her make them articulate. But now I think Ashlee might have brought the articulateness as well. Maybe Kara needs her own Kara DioGuardi, someone to do for her what she did for Lindsay, draw her out, find a way to make her words and sounds into her words and sounds.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 7 September 2006 12:24 (seventeen years ago) link

I just built a Pandora station off "Since U Been Gone" and "Kiss" and some other stuff but those are the two it seems to be favoring. Started off with a run of pop-punk, then some soul that I mostly vetoed (sorry) and then some odd choices (B-52s, Big Audio Dynamite!) and now it's into some solid teenpop (Veronicas, Liz Phair) but it's already given me a few things I'm totally surprised and pleased by: "Tena's Song" by Foxy (which I know nothing about but like) and "Only One Too" by Jewel which is actually fairly awesome! And now Aly and AJ of course, which I don't think I like. Anyway, I had no idea the Jewel was that good, nice and Matrix-y. It's interesting that it went in a much more teenpop direction once I added "Gigantic."

Eppy (Eppy), Thursday, 7 September 2006 16:50 (seventeen years ago) link

"Collapsed"? That's the only Aly and AJ song I've ever heard on Pandora for some reason. Jewel's teenpop turn is generally overlooked (compared to, say, Liz Phair), but what I've heard of it is awesome. And yeah, it's cool to see Pandora attempt to define the "roots" of teenpop empirically. My editing has been kind of heavy-handed lately, though, when they build from an unlikely (often good) choice, it tends to venture quickly into stuff I don't like. Six degrees of separation, but in two turns it's twelve, etc.

Still haven't heard any Platinum Weird outside Myspace.

nameom (nameom), Thursday, 7 September 2006 17:04 (seventeen years ago) link


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.