HBO adaptation of Game of Thrones - will this be just for nerds? (NO SPOILERS PLEASE)

fully expect Martin to die without finishing the series tbh

JESUS, SPOILERS MAN.

I'd be happy with more redheads, tbqfh

I'm on the last book, and keep putting off reading it so that I can stay in that world. Which on reflection is a bit sad.

The second and third books are the best in the series, although I've been putting off reading the fifth until the sixth is truly on the horizon.

My point above was simply that if you are SO CONCERNED about spoilers (it's just a tv show guys), then go out and read the books. You either care about this story, or you don't. Being invested in the tv show and not reading the books is weak. Saying, "I make time to watch television, but not to read novels," will not gain my respect.

Sure, GRRM is not Faulkner. Nor is he trying to be. But he's an immaculate craftsman and storyteller. I haven't had a writer's hooks that deep in me for a while. Literally could not wait to read what would happen next, until I reached the fourth book, which I consider the "methadone" book.

For my money, the best literary fantasy stylist is Gene Wolfe. And you can stack him against Joyce and Faulkner and literally anyone else you can think of.

Fingers crossed that when this series is complete, HBO will option Wolfe's Book of the New Sun next. It could use more boobs too.

i read lots of books. i'm also enjoying this TV show, and enjoying being surprised by it. i don't need some sanctimonious asshole criticizing any of the above. thanks!

Yup

My point above was simply that if you are SO CONCERNED about spoilers (it's just a tv show guys), then go out and read the books. You either care about this story, or you don't. Being invested in the tv show and not reading the books is weak. Saying, "I make time to watch television, but not to read novels," will not gain my respect.

I've read the books but consider this a particularly dickish POV.

You either care about this story, or you don't.

what if you care about the story but not about the "scrollwork" on everybody's "doublets"

i mean i read (three of) them but only because my name is theon so it was a fascinating novelty

I don't think anyone cares about gaining your respect for reading a half-dozen fantasy novels, tbh.

you all sound like dicks now

what is the sound of one dick clapping

remarkably similar to the sound of Martin typing

responding to someone you think is being sanctimonious by calling them an asshole is some bullshit.

Gonorrheaing

it funny though, GOT does seem to occupy a fairly unique position with regard to spoilers. I can't think of any other adaptation that's inspired such animosity between readers and non-readers

There is a separate spoiler end thread to avoid this kind of hogwash.

Spoilered*

exactly, the fact that two threads are required at all is unusual

it's almost like this story exists in two different formats

It's unique in that a serialised television show is an adaptation of a series of books.

so is True Blood. I doubt anyone gives a shit about spoilers for that

ditto Dexter, although I gather the show went its own way after season 1

wasn't Walking Dead a comic book...?

Boardwalk Empire also an adaptation of some bio iirc

one book != a series

the list of television shows based off of comic books is ludicrously long

http://www.twonkhammer.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/monopoly-man.jpg

how many tv shows based on informative pamphlets/brochures I wonder

This show has deviated plenty.

I found the second season kind of sad. The "battle" of the Blackwater was pathetic. I knew they wouldn't have the cast of thousands necessary, but the 60 dudes they had made it worse than if they hadn't shown it.

Nah the Blackwater battle was great. They did a really good job of scaling it down without making it look cheesy, I thought. I mean, it's never gonna match what's in your head.

At least they didn't just have Tyrion pass out at the beginning only to wake up in the aftermath.

I thought it was cheesy as hell. You can't make King's Landing so big and have that handful be the invasion force. You either need to scale it all down or make sure your shots don't show that the line of men is twenty across and three deep.

isn't that what cgi is for

My point above was simply that if you are SO CONCERNED about spoilers (it's just a tv show guys), then go out and read the books.

Ok - some of us are A) dyslexic and painfully slow readers; and B) incredibly busy with jobs and families and all that silly stuff and just don't have the time to read a bazillion pages worth of some fantasy books, simply to satisfy some smug, ignorant internet jerk-offs who are too lazy to find the thread specifically for the people who *have* read the mother fucking books.

also, i thought the blackwater battle was great.

The way people on this thread respond to someone telling you the books are worth reading is enlightening. you guys deserve this shitty tv adaptation.

it's all love up in here, huh

isn't that what cgi is for

― Welcome to my world of proses (Shakey Mo Collier), Wednesday, February 6, 2013 9:20 PM (11 minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

no, *this* is what cgi is for

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FddHy44cwsw

WE MUST FORM CLANS AND BATTLE TO THE DEATH

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K8BPP4ASQWo

Glasgow Film Featival is screening "Blackwater" followed by a q+a with the cast (who? I don't know). Kind of want to go but after the EFF Serenity screening and q+a I think I'd just cringe a lot.

BTW you guys Jaime Lannister is in the new horror film Mama and it's hella distracting for awhile.

Stannis was in Zero Dark Thirty

Cersei was the villain in Dredd, Mr Veg and I spent the first half of the movie waiting for them to introduce a sibling character for her to have sexytimes with

Melisandre will always, for me, be first and foremost the hott witch in Black Death.

Odd to look back and see Grandpa Lannister fighting off a Xenomorph in Alien 3.

Melissandre also as the Dutch resistance nazi killer in Voerhoeven's flick

I will always think of Dinklage as the guy in The Station Agent.

The way people on this thread respond to someone telling you the books are worth reading is enlightening.

If you're referring to me – I was not responding to someone say "oh hay, check out the books, you will like them" I was incensed at someone, too lazy to post in the thread made just for them to talk about what happens in the books; telling me how to live my life. I'm sure the books are great – if reading comes easy to you and you have a surplus of free time.