"Got to give it up" Vs "Don't stop til you get enough"

Marvin's is cool and "don't stop" is far from my favourite MJ tracks but it's still amazing.

How does this tie into Blurred Lines?

uh ? well, the "got to give it up"/"don't stop" parallel was discussed in the "blurred lines" thread and I thought it was interesting, that's all !

But what does this mean?

i.e not what Thicke and Pharrell did with "Blurred Lines" which is fun but still...).

Sorry if I'm coming off all Tuomas here. I've got a head full of cough syrup right now.

ah, it means "don't stop" was heavily inspired by "got to give" but became something new and great/better whereas "blurred lines" was heavily influenced by the same song but is just a fun variation of it. I enjoy it as a good summer jam, though !
it's just about transcending (or not) your inspiration.

(no worries, I'm a bit dizzy with the temperature and maybe not too clear !)

Neither as good as #beautiful you cunts

ahah. reminds me of someone...

words won't bring us down

got to give it up > don't stop til you get enough > blurred lines

"Got To Give It Up" isn't even my favorite Gaye song from the period ("Ego Trippin' Out" wins), so I vote for "Don't Stop..."

eto's great, but

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ghbFqCZuqG8

is one of the best things done by a person

I'm guessing G2GIU scores higher on the disco poll given the lack of competing Gaye disco.

haw

I always thought "Don't Stop" was basically a lesser rehash of "Shake Your Body" (which I preferred and still do) and I got weirdly resentful as an 11-year old when it overtook "Body" on the local pop chart. And then "Don't Stop" won the Grammy and became a classic while "Shake Your Body" was virtually forgotten, and I became deeply cynical.

So I'd give it up for "Got To Give It Up" out of pure spite even if I didn't prefer it.

Yeah, I still prefer "Shake Your Body" too; it doesn't seem as beaten into the ground. As much as I've played both DJing out, I never really noticed the similarity between the Green and MJ tracks, and I'm not sure I ever sequed them together. (These days my go-to Jackson-related cut is "Hum Along And Dance")

this is a REALLY tough decision

Green should be Gaye there, obviously.

(These days my go-to Jackson-related cut is "Hum Along And Dance")

otm

I have always loved "shake your body" but the production is nowhere close to the near perfection of the tracks on "off the wall" and "thriller".
I'm not a big fan of "don't stop" but it sounds amazing !

Oh yeah, production on "Don't Stop" >>>>>> "Got To..." Gaye kinda simmers along (BPM experts could tell me the difference between the two) - it's a great groove, but it doesn't have the wow factor of the MJ.

I have always loved "shake your body" but the production is nowhere close to the near perfection of the tracks on "off the wall" and "thriller".

This. "Shake Your Body" is great. "Don't Stop" is a masterpiece.

(And "Wanna Be Startin Somethin" may be better than either, if you wanna talk about MJ things that got unfairly overshadowed by other MJ things.)

oh yeah, "wanna be startin" might be his greatest moment ever, not necessarily in terms of songwriting but just... the sound of the future (with Giorgio's voice) !

The origins of "Wanna Be..." as documented in the Nelson George book on Thriller are awesome. Apparently the West African performer who came up with the chant got points on the song, so he's a very rich man, I hope.

Manu Dibango, or did it come from someone else?

yeah, I think it was Dibango's soul makossa ?

Gaye kinda simmers along (BPM experts could tell me the difference between the two) - it's a great groove, but it doesn't have the wow factor of the MJ.

― Byron E. Coli (Dan Peterson), Wednesday, July 24, 2013 8:56 AM (19 minutes ago)

that's not a slam dunk though. i love the earthy, effortless groove that simmers under "got to give it up". something slightly wounded (or at least fragile) about it, darker & dirtier than any mj i know. it's not a knockout, it's an embrace, gentle at that. depends what you want.

"Got to give" has a great groove but it's more laid back.
like a smooth before party with drinks with some friends.
"don't stop" is the moment the party goes full blast !

I'm fine being in both places.

My fave gaye track vs. A pretty good song from an artist I can't stand = no contest

actually, I much prefer the smooth before party drinks with some friends !

Apparently the West African performer who came up with the chant got points on the song, so he's a very rich man, I hope.

Actually, Manu Dibango sued MJ and they settled out of court. Then he more recently sued again when Rihanna sampled it; she got permission from MJ but not Manu: http://pitchfork.com/news/34538-manu-dibango-sues-rihanna-michael-jackson/

"don't stop" is my favorite mj song (out of many that i love by him). "got to give it up" is great but i gotta go with mj here.

voted Marvin

feel like gtgiu is a fun gaye song, but only a modest sliver of what he could and did do, while dstyge is a dancefloor kaiju whatever your opinion of mj

Only one of these is the black national anthem

(Possibly replaced by "Wobble")

my parents' macbook plays DSTYGE during slideshows

The "Let's dance/ Let's Shout/ ....." chant in "Shake Your Body (Down to the Ground" is directly taken from "Got to Give It Up"

otm

Marvin.

They are both sublime but I could very well never choose to hear DSTYGE again (but love it when i do hear it) while the Marvin is go-to track.

this is pretty much impossible

I probably rate "Shake Your Body" over either tbh

Shake Your Body >>> Don't Stop >>>>>> Got to Give It Up

yeah, i might put shake on top, right before got to give it up. tough call tho.

Full version of Got To Give It Up is basically life, no? I mean, I know there are other songs but I don't know why they bother.

yeah, on 2nd, even "shake your body" has to fall

there is no higher higher

CB RADIO FORD MEATHEAD CHINA FORD WATERGATE

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

wrong

I can't remember how I voted tbh

rong rong rong rong

i voted 54.7619% michael and 45.2381% marvin, so that is how i broke it down to an extent.

Just realized I could live with either result, so ...

no man... you don't have to live with this. don't think you have to live with this.

just happy that 19 people know who marvin gaye is